In this week’s contribution to the Looking Back at the 2019 Reds series, we are going to look back at All-Star pitcher Luis Castillo.

The Preseason Projection

Luis Castillo entered the season in his mid-20’s, coming in at 26-years-old. While pitchers tend to age a little differently than position players do, pitchers in their mid-20’s should certainly be near their prime much like hitters of the game age.

Here’s what Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS projections for the 2019 season had to say for the Cincinnati Reds right-handed pitcher:

IP ERA H HR BB K WHIP ERA+
161.0 3.91 148 23 48 159 1.22 108

The 2019 Season

Looking at the pre-season projection, Luis Castillo was looking like an above-average starter, but not by a whole lot. One thing with projections, particularly with starting pitchers, is that they rarely forecast a full season of starts for anyone – simply because that’s the nature of pitching.

Luis Castillo has been healthy for his entire big league career. He was only in his second full season, but he made all 32 starts in 2019 after making all 31 the year before, and all 15 after being called up mid-season in 2017. Not missing any time allowed him to best the projection in innings, and as such, walks, and strikeouts, too.

In the first half of the season he was downright dominant. In the 18 starts he made in the first half he posted a 2.29 ERA in 106.0 innings and allowed just 62 hits, with nine home runs, 53 walks, and 124 strikeouts. His walk rate was higher than you want it to be, but everything else was outstanding. That earned him a nod on the National League All-Star team – the first time he had been named to the game.

In his second half, though, things weren’t quite as good. His ERA more than doubled, jumping to 4.78 in the final 14 starts of the year. He threw 84.2 innings and allowed 77 hits – with 13 of those being home runs. That also came with 26 walks and 102 strikeouts. The walk rate dropped off in the second half – something that hopefully continues into 2020.

Overall those two halves combined for an above-average season. He would throw 190.2 innings, a career best, with a 3.40 ERA. In a season where the baseball flew out of stadiums at a historic rate he gave up just 22 home runs (after giving up 28 in 2018 in 21 fewer innings). Oh, and he racked up 226 strikeouts while posting a 1.14 WHIP. His WAR was 4.4 (Baseball Reference) or 4.1 (Fangraphs) depending on which version you prefer.

What happened?

Well, what happened was that Luis Castillo beat out his projections across the board, with the exception of his walk rate. He remained healthy, he took steps forward, was named an All-Star, and was one of the better starting pitchers in the National League during 2019.

Some of that was due to the fact that he threw fewer fastballs than ever before, while working in more change ups. His slider rate stayed about the same as it has been the previous two years.

But let’s talk a little bit more about the first half and second half, because the difference in ERA was massive.

There were three big differences between the two halves. The walk rate was much lower in the second half. And the batting average on balls in play was much lower in the first half. The home run rate was also much higher in the second half. It was the home run rate and the batting average on balls in play both going up that resulted in the much higher ERA in the second half, even with the big drop off in walks.

Season Stats

W L ERA IP H HR BB K WHIP
15 8 3.40 190.2 139 22 79 226 1.14

What’s to come?

That’s a fun question, isn’t it? In the first year with Derek Johnson as the pitching coach, nearly every pitcher on the staff took a step forward. What does year two have in store? Will the second half walk rate carry forward? Will Major League Baseball fix the issues with the baseball, which could lead to lower home run rates across the board for everyone in the game?

Among qualified starting pitchers he had the second best groundball rate in baseball last season at 55.2%. He was also only one of three pitchers to finish in the top 15 in both groundball rate and strikeout rate. The other two were Stephen Strasburg and Sonny Gray. Turns out being good at both of those things tends to work out for a pitcher. If the baseball issues are fixed in, that combination could be really, really fun moving forward.

17 Responses

  1. Colt Holt

    My takeaway from the what’s to come is that the reds should sign Strasburg. I am totally convinced.

  2. James H.

    Could there be a correlation between poor defense and the higher batting average over his 2nd half of the season?

    • Doug Gray

      Possible, but very, very unlikely given the difference. If the gap were a lot smaller, it could be a reasonable explanation. But not at this rate.

  3. Jeff

    One thing that seems to make Castillo effective is the swing-and-miss rate out of the K zone. Is it possible that his push for fewer walks created more hitable pitches, therefore raising ERA etc in 2nd half? Haven’t looked at all the other related numbers but that seems plausible.

  4. Hotto4Votto

    M’s reportedly considering dealing C Omar Narvaez. Really good bat, suspect defense. Controlled for 3 ARB years. Probably better than the FA options, but would cost more than just payroll. Something to think about since the C market leaves a lot to be desired and M’s GM loves making trades.

    • BK

      He would certainly provide an offensive upgrade and would make a lot of sense if the Reds thought they could improve his defense. Of course, what would the Mariners want in return?

  5. JB WV

    I always suspect arm fatigue for such a drastic difference between halves. But hitters were swinging early in counts in the second half so they weren’t at the mercy of that nasty change up and had more success. Not too big an issue to overcome next year. He’s a joy to watch.

    • David

      I think arm fatigue is a common reason for young-ish guys to fade in a long baseball season. They still aren’t quite conditioned to reach about 200 innings from the limits placed in the minor leagues, where they might only hit 120-140 innings.
      I don’t know if his velocity fell off a little, but sometimes overall fatigue just means your mechanics get a little sloppy sometimes, and location is not ideal (more pitches up in the zone). Castillo will get “stronger” in terms of stamina and staying power.

      Remembering Johnny Cueto, and how he became a conditioning demon. Sure, he looked kind of round and pudgy, but he was strong and had a lot of stamina as he matured.

  6. Steve Schoenbaechler

    Definitely an improvement. If he starts out next season like this one, we are probably going to extend him, buying out some of those arbitration years.

  7. KDJ

    Doug, thanks for providing daily Reds thoughts even this time of year.

    • Doug Gray

      I figure that I might as well write as many things as I can now since I get a feeling after 2021 there’s going to be a lot less to write about…..

      • Michael Smith

        Doug ill crowd source your new website for foodies in 2021.

  8. Telecaster

    Castillo was great after his initial call up in 2017. Entering 2018 expectations were high and he sputtered out of the gate before returning to form. In 2019 of course he took off like a rocket before shuffling across the finish line. Now he’s ready to put it all together starting his third full season. I see 20-7 with 2.93 era 200+ innings and strikeouts. Go reds!

  9. AirborneJayJay

    Could some of the “money to spend” go to Castillo on an extension this winter? It wouldn’t affect the budget of 2020 much at all. Probably not much in 2021. But it would definitely start to show up in the 2022 budgets and beyond.
    No other Reds player demonstrated in 2019 that an extension would be warranted. They can lock up Castillo this winter and look to maybe add a year or two to Gray’s deal. These 2 should anchor the rotation for the next 5 years. And next winter look to possibly do the same with Winker and/or Senzel and/or Aquino if either busts out.

    • Colt Holt

      Disco, Garrett, lorenzen, Stephenson, senzel should all be considered.

      Disco guaranteed through 22 at ten to twelve per with an option.

      Garrett, lorenzen, Stephenson getting a couple free agent years at $7 per with two options at $8 per.

      Senzel with $28-30M guaranteed through 2026, two options at $12 per. He may not have “earned it”, but if he had, the cost would correspond. He has the talent that you happily take the risk of guaranteeing $30 mill on the chance he becomes a superstar and pays ten fold.

  10. Old-school

    Jason Stark at the Athletic looks back at the decade of 2010-19. Joey Votto finishes as the #2 player of the decade . He and Mike trout were the only players to finish .300/.400/.500 for the decade. Jv .306/.428/.516. he walked 1046x, more than 200 more than #2. He was the best on base machine of the decade.

    Votto needs some more counting numbers for HOF but being the best player in a decade for the NL should get him in. He needs 16 HR for 300 and 56 RBi for 1000 and 144 hits for 2000. He’s already scored 1000 runs and hit 400 doubles .

    A bounce back year and JV could cement his place in history.

    Billy Hamilton had the worst slugging percentage for the decade at .326 and the worst OPS of the decade at .623.