Today at 8PM is the deadline that Major League Baseball teams have for adding players to the 40-man roster in order to protect them from the upcoming Rule 5 draft.

A quick primer on this is that players who were signed to minor league contracts (either drafted or signed as international free agents) who were under 19 when they signed, are eligible for the Rule 5 and have five years of professional play if not placed on the 40-man roster. Players who were 19 or older are eligible after they have four years of professional play and not placed on the 40-man roster. For domestic players, that means college players drafted in 2016 or earlier, and high school players drafted in 2015 or earlier. International players you need to use their age and contract signed.

Players who are left unprotected and drafted by another organization must remain on that teams Major League roster all season. If they are not the player will be placed on waivers and any other team can claim them with the stipulation that they also must abide by those Rule 5 rules. If the player clears waivers then they must be offered back to their original team.

Over the last week I have written about 25 players in detail that are Rule 5 eligible from the Cincinnati Reds farm system over at RedsMinorLeagues.com who the team has probably had at least some sort of conversation about protecting. I’m not going to regurgitate that here at Redleg Nation – but you can check that all out if you’d like to. What I do want to do here today is look at the players that I do expect the Reds to protect today.

The current 40-man roster has 35 players on it. The Reds could protect up to five players today without removing someone currently on the roster. My belief is that they will add five players, filling up the roster. That won’t come into play for more than two weeks when it comes to free agency or trades as I believe the team will trim the roster with non-tenders on or before the December 2nd deadline that will clear some roster spots. There’s also a chance that they place players on waivers today to try and sneak them through after teams begin to fill up their rosters with their own moves.

Let’s get into the players that the team will protect.

The Pitchers the Reds Will Protect

This year is a bit light on the pitchers that are likely to be protected. My expectation is that the Cincinnati Reds will only protect two pitchers – one starter and one reliever.

The starter is an easy choice. Tony Santillan was a Top 100 prospect during the season, even though his 2019 season was a bit down from his breakout 2018 campaign between Advanced-A and Double-A. The 2015 2nd round pick out of high school will show three plus pitches at times, along with a solid fourth offering. His 2019 season was mangled by a few non-serious injuries that he pitched with, but also saw some injured list time with. He’s currently rated as the Reds 5th best prospect.

The reliever isn’t much of a tough decision in my mind either. Ryan Hendrix was the 5th round pick out of Texas A&M back in 2016 and he’s dominated since being signed. His career ERA is 2.55 in the minors – and it’s been under 1.90 in each of the last two seasons while pitching in Advanced-A and Double-A. In 2019 he only threw 19.1 innings for Double-A Chattanooga – missing three months with an injury before returning for the final month of the season. When healthy he’s got two plus pitches and perhaps the best two-pitch combo of any pitcher in the organization not named Hunter Greene. He is currently rated as the Reds 16th best prospect.

Other names to keep an eye on

If you clicked on the link at the top of the story for all of the player write ups you are probably aware of these guys. As I said, I don’t want to rehash all of that here, though. But there are some guys that have an outside chance of being selected if they go unprotected, meaning the Reds could use a spot to add them if they think they could lose them. Tejay Antone had some success in Triple-A this season after having lots of it in Double-A this year. He’s a ground ball machine who could have a 2-pitch arsenal play up out of the bullpen after starting for his entire minor league career. Jhon de Jesus has only pitched in Low-A for his highest level, and his ERA wasn’t good this season while there. But he’s got real stuff, and real size. It only takes one scout to believe and sell their brass – and there have certainly been worse selections in the long history of the Rule 5.

On the reliever side of things you’ve got a guy like Aneurys Zabala who has been up to 102 MPH with his fastball, but has control issues. Then there are guys with solid, but not elite stuff but big results in Advanced-A ball this year in Connor Bennett, Dauri Moreta, and Diomar Lopez – the latter two who spent time in the Arizona Fall League and showed their stuff to scouts all over baseball as a result. Wild card Alexis Diaz has some stuff and good secondary stats, but did post an ERA of 5.18 in Low-A Dayton this year. And then there’s Brandon Finnegan, who didn’t pitch this year until late July and only threw a handful of innings this season with uninspiring results. Still, if someone thinks they can fix him, you have seen what’s potentially in there.

The Position Players the Reds Will Protect

For me there are two players that should make the “easy to protect” side of the ledger. That third spot is reserved for plenty of debate.

The first name on the list is 2015 1st round pick Tyler Stephenson. The catcher has worked his way up the farm system, topping out in Double-A this past season where he was above-average at the plate while being one of the younger players in the league. He then went to the Arizona Fall League and hit .353/.421/.549 in his 51 at-bats. Stephenson has the tools and the production has followed as he’s remained healthy over the last two seasons. Easy, easy selection for the Reds 3rd rated prospect.

The next name would be TJ Friedl. The outfielder went undrafted out of Nevada back in 2016, but a lot of teams failed at their jobs and didn’t know that he was draft eligible. After joining Team USA that summer and going on a tear teams began to look at him to prepare for the 2017 draft, only to then realize he was eligible that year and since he went unselected, he was now a free agent. The Reds took advantage of their draft position, which comes with more bonus pool money, and they used what they had remaining before facing penalties of 1st round draft pick forfeiture to sign him to the largest domestic signing bonus ever to an undrafted free agent.

Much like his teammate this year in Double-A Tony Santillan, health was a bit of an issue for TJ Friedl in 2019. An ankle injury would take out his season early in July as he needed surgery to get back to full health. He hit just .235 on the year up to that point, but posted a .347 on-base percentage and slugged .385. When he’s healthy he has always hit better than that. He makes contact, he draws walks, he can run very well, and he can play a quality center field. Friedl may not be Major League ready today, but he will be soon. With a floor of a 4th outfielder and a ceiling as a starting center fielder, the Reds 11th rated prospect is an easy choice to add.

The final player that I believe will be protected today is shortstop Alfredo Rodriguez. The Reds signed him out of Cuba in the summer of 2016. He’s struggled to hit for the most part ever since – but that isn’t surprising given that just about every scouting report suggested that he was a great glove guy who couldn’t hit. He slugged under .300 in Cuba. But in 2019 at Double-A he did have his best offensive season.He hit .286/.325/.347 in 104 games for the Chattanooga Lookouts – all career bests. But for those keeping track at home, that’s still an OPS of .672 for a 25-year-old in Double-A, with a grand total of one home run.

He did move up to Triple-A in August, and with a juiced Major League Baseball in play where teams were decimating offensive records all year he hit .169/.261/.221 in 23 games played. Rodriguez has been playing in the Dominican Winter League this offseason, and through 19 games he’s hitting .309/.351/.324. He has one double – his only extra-base hit of the season.

The call here is interesting. Would a team really take a solid, but not elite defensive infielder who doesn’t have much of any offensive upside to speak of who will turn 26 next year? I don’t believe that they would, and if the decision were left to me, he would go unprotected. It’s just hard to make the argument that a team would take a career .252/.302/.310 hitter who is already 25-years-old. And if someone does, are you really feeling as if you lost out on more than an emergency call up?

But things aren’t always that simple. The Reds spent nearly $9M to sign Alfredo Rodriguez after you include the penalty they paid Major League Baseball to sign him for going over their pool allotment in 2016. That’s a lot of money, and while there’s the whole sunk cost thing, it doesn’t mean that everyone follows that to a T. Telling your owner that the player he spent $9M on isn’t worthy of being protected and someone else can have him for $100,000 and a spot on the 40-man probably isn’t a great conversation to have. For that reason, I expect Rodriguez to be added to the roster.

Other names to keep an eye on

Ibandel Isabel would have been a minor league free agent, but the Reds re-signed him before he tested the waters. In 2018 he broke the Florida State League record for home runs, hitting 35 in just 104 games to break the record that had stood for 71 years. This past season he played in just 91 games, but still led the Double-A Southern League with 26 homers. With that incredible power, though, comes an incredibly high strikeout rate. This season he struck out 42% of the time he stepped to the plate, hitting .243/.307/.518 on the year.

There are a few athletic outfielders with some tools that could be considered, too. Narciso Crook is the most advanced of the bunch and split his time in Double-A and Triple-A this season. In 108 games he hit .277/.332/.474 between the two stops. He can play left or right field, and he’s more than capable of being a back up center fielder defensively – but he’s probably not a guy you start there every day. He’s got some pop, a little bit of speed, and covers three spots. And he’ll be 24-years-old next year – so age is working with him, too.

The other two outfielders are ones with tools at the lower levels of the minors. Andy Sugilio may be the fastest player in the organization, can play center field, and has some upside at the plate. But he also has struggled to show much of that upside at the plate on the field. There’s some power potential, but his incredibly high ground ball rates keep him from getting to it. He hit .294/.331/.360 for Advanced-A Daytona this year.

Mariel Bautista is the Reds 18th rated prospect following a down season. He’s a potential 5-tool player who has plus speed and plus raw-power. And prior to 2019 he had hit at least .320 for three consecutive seasons. But he struggled to find consistency at the plate in 2019 for the Low-A Dayton Dragons, hitting .233/.303/.332 with 19 steals in 103 games. He did miss a month with a shoulder injury early in the season, which may have played a bit into the production issues.

30 Responses

  1. Hotto4Votto

    There’s no way in the world I’d waste a spot protecting Alf-Rod. He makes Billy Hamilton look like Barry Bonds at the plate. The Reds made a poor decision signing him to that much money in the first place, don’t double down on the mistake by adding him to the roster when he’s undeserving.

    Add Antone or Crook as the fifth spot, both carry value for next year’s team as depth. Or, leave the spot open to add someone in Rule V. Either choice is a better option. The Reds FO has been operating too shrewdly of late to go back to making such poor decisions.

  2. Greg

    No on AlfRod. I have been mad about that one since before he was signed officially. Rule “V” is the best time of the year.

  3. BK

    Another thing to watch for is players DFA today as teams clear roster space to add top prospects to their rosters. There are some teams out there with pretty tight 40-man rosters.

  4. BK

    I agree that AlfRod is on the bubble. What he really has going for him is that he can play, at least defensively, SS at the MLB level. Right now, Galvis and Peraza are the only two SS on the 40-man roster:

    – I anticipate Peraza is traded or non-tendered. The Reds simply won’t go into a season with the goal of reaching the playoffs and Peraza in the starting lineup. Moreover, he hasn’t adapted the role of utility player that his defensive versatility suggest he should be ideal for. I could see him being moved to a rebuilding team for another non-tender candidate.

    – Galvis is our current top option for SS, but I anticipate the Reds will try to improve at SS. In a bench role, Galvis $5.5M salary is a bit high. He’s a quality, low-floor player. I could easily see the Reds trading him if he was part of a package that brought back a SS, CF, or solid player with team control. They could also retain him, but the point is he is not a core player.

    Placing AlfRod on the 40-man roster gives the Reds the opportunity to move either or both of Peraza and Galvis and plan for a 26-man roster that doesn’t have a true SS as a backup. Farmer, Blandino and even VanMeter could all cover SS on a limited basis and all have proven to be solid bench players. They also cost less than either Galvis or Peraza. So going with them gives the Reds the potential to reallocate salary to higher priority positions.

    If AlfRod sticks, it won’t be because the Reds are smarting over the $9M sunk cost (DW is a professionally trained investment banker, he gets the idea of sunk cost). It will be because they AlfRod as an emergency SS that can be stashed at Louisville next summer. Further, he can easily be dropped from the 40-man if a better player comes along. It’s not like our 40-man roster is teeming with high-end talent, there is room, at least today.

    • Tom Mitsoff

      We’ve seen a lot of slick-fielding shortstops who couldn’t hit in the minors who went on to prove that they couldn’t hit in the majors. It seems that AlfRod is on that track. The front office has to be smart and protect someone who has more potential upside at the big-league level. It’s really hard to imagine that any team would keep AlfRod on the major league roster all season, especially with the reduced value of defensive excellence (as opposed to offensive production) at all positions. The days of glove-first players like shortstop Mark Belanger having long major-league careers as starters are long gone.

      • BK

        I agree Tom. Four prospects are pretty easy choices. The next set of prospects, including AlfRod, are hard to see losing. Losing AlfRod or any of the other bubble players wouldn’t be a great loss to the Reds. AlfRod is the one player I can see the Reds wanting to hold onto through the offseason. That said, I won’t be at all surprised (or disappointed) if he’s left off the roster.

    • Doug Gray

      I’ve seen the “Alfredo Rodriguez can play shortstop and the Reds only have two of those guys” argument a few times, and while that’s probably true – it shouldn’t matter. You can pick up a shortstop in minor league free agency who can’t hit the ball out of the infield and play him in Triple-A next year if you need that kind of depth. It won’t cost you a 40-man spot.

      • BK

        Good point on minor league signing route … I’m pushing back on the notion that they would only add him to the 40-man to save face with the ownership. While sentimental/emotional decisions have been a hallmark of the Reds, more recent evidence is their decision making has been well-reasoned. If they add him to the 40-man, it will be because they think it’s the right baseball decision. My guess is that they go with only the top four you suggested in anticipation that they are going to bring in some free agents. Of course, they don’t have to have to clear the space now. If I personally were going to add a fifth player today it would be Antone–as a groundball pitcher he’s a good fit in GABP, big-league ready now and the Reds are thin on big league ready starters with minor league options so he fills a need.

    • Hotto4Votto

      Counterpoint: Blake Trahan. He appears to be every bit the SS that Alf-Rod is, and has shown more positional flexibility in his career. Their hitting profile has been pretty similar in the minors. The Reds kept him on the 40-man through the offseason last year and when their projected starting SS moved to 2B, they slotted in a minor league FA, and Trahan never received the call. Zach Vincej the year before came up, and had been a better hitter, taken off and claimed, but does anyone miss him?

      The point being, the Reds will figure out a better option than Alf-Rod if they suddenly find themselves with need at the position. If the Reds are serious about contending then Alf-Rod has no business being near a ML roster. If Alf-Rod is drafted (which is highly doubtful) it’s doubtful that the Reds will miss him. If they add him now and later need that spot, it becomes more likely (though still not very likely) someone would claim him without the pressure of keeping him on the ML roster all year. Their best bet is to leave him off and see if he can make any progress next season.

      • BK

        I agree with you that Trahan fills the same role and is unlikely to get taken in the Rule 5 draft either. He’s currently listed on the Bats roster and doesn’t have 6 years in MiLB so he shouldn’t be a free agent.

        However, he was on the Reds 40-man all offseason and remained there until early August when he was DFA. He also missed a good bit of time injured last season and neither Iglesias or Peraza missed any appreciable time. So while agree AlfRod is likely left off the 40-man, the Reds followed the exact scenario I described in my initial post last offseason.

        http://www.milb.com/player/index.jsp?sid=t416&player_id=664167#/career/R/hitting/2019/ALL

      • Hotto4Votto

        Right, same scenario, but never needed him, and when they had a need they utilized someone else and added him to the roster. You said if he’s added they can stash him until he’s needed for an emergency. I’m saying, like Trahan, even in an emergency they wouldn’t use him because they can always bring in someone better.

      • BK

        Once more, I don’t think they will add AlfRod, today, but IF they do, it will be for a baseball reason (want a backup SS on the 40-man for an emergency) NOT because they made a big (now looking pretty bad) investment. Trahan’s presence, minor league free agents, and the low probability that another team drafts him are all great reasons to protect a different player. I prefer Antone as the fifth player if the Reds want to protect that many, but after the top 4 (Santillan, Stephenson, Hendrix and Friedl), I am rather ambivalent.

      • Hotto4Votto

        (Hopefully this isn’t coming across as argumentative, I like hashing these things out.). I’m not suggesting you’re saying add him. You’ve been clear about that. I’m saying that the baseball reason to add him is largely irrelevant based on what happened with Trahan. If the baseball reasoning is to have an emergency SS stashed in AAA in case of injury, I’m saying the Reds likely don’t call him up even in an emergency situation. It’s more likely they acquire someone who can actually contribute to the team. He’d be extremely overmatched at the plate and if the Reds are serious about competing they cannot afford to bring him up just because he’s on the roster.

        But, we certainly agree that he shouldn’t be added, and agree it would be wiser to add Antone. Hopefully the FO agrees too.

      • BK

        Couldn’t agree more! I appreciate the dialogue.

  5. jim walker

    With 26 man rosters and pitcher numbers capped, I think that somebody in the DH league may well have a look a Isabel if he is available. Costs what? $50K for a look with a 50% refund if you offer him back and the Reds take him? In an era of three true outcomes, why not?

    • Doug Gray

      $100,000 up front, 50% back. But why not is simple: The 40-man spot is quite valuable. That’s not to say someone won’t take him – but between that spot not being available to you right now, and the fact that Double-A pitching had him striking out 42% of the time – it’s a real risky proposition.

    • Optimist

      Anybody remember Kennys Vargas and his 3-day Reds career? Is Ibandel all that different? 5 years younger, same K/BB ratio – I suppose Ibandel has tapped into the power a degree or two better than Vargas, but would his MLB line look any different given the playing time?

    • Colorado Red

      I the 26th man, does make a big difference.
      You can take a guy with potential, and put him on the 26 (hard to say) that for a year,then send him down.
      I like Ibandel Isabel, I would rather spend a spot on the 40-man on him.

  6. AirborneJayJay

    There is no way on this earth that AlfRod should be added to the Reds 40-man roster. Not if Jose Garcia is supposed to be all that and a bag of chips. If some team wants to take AlfRod that is fine. The problem will be next year when that team will have to return him to the Reds after that team decides that AlfRod isn’t what they thought.
    Antone is the one I would give that 5th roster spot to. He has a chance to help the Reds in 2020. He will start the season at AAA but is a phone call away. His pitching has been improving the more he progresses from that TJ surgery. My prediction is he will be pitching the best at AAA as a starter next year. Sims doesn’t look like he will be at AAA Louisville next year. He is out of options and there is no way he will go through waivers unclaimed.
    Roll the dice on AlfRod being unprotected. Don’t do it with Antone, put him on the 40 man.

    • Big Ed

      I am in favor of their turning AlfRod into a pitcher. What do they have to lose?

  7. BK

    As I was scanning the list of players that are under consideration for being added to their team’s 40-man roster, 25-year old Jake Cronenworth, a two-way player at SS and RHP at AAA (.334/.429/.520) with the Tampa Rays stood out. He’s outside the BA Top 10 prospects for the Rays. On mlb.com’s list, he is the #4 SS or 6 in the Ray’s Top 20. The scouting reports say he can hit and stick at SS defensively. Of course the best position player on their roster is a SS and the #1 prospect in baseball is a Rays SS. In short, the Rays are loaded at SS and their 40-man roster is tight. One of their biggest needs is a catcher to pair with the LH-hitting Michael Perez. Trading the Curt Casali would allow the Rays to save about $3M by nontendering their current second catcher, Mike Zunino opening up a 40-man roster spot. The Reds would then plan to open the season with Kyle Farmer as the backup catcher based on our current roster, but add a potential long-term, bat-first SS.

  8. Seat101

    What is “rule V”?

    Let’s just call him “Alfred” and be done with it.

    Take it for what it’s worth but a friend of mine with tenuous ties to the Houston Astros says the Astros really like TJ Friedl.

  9. MK

    Let’s be realistic about Rodriguez. There are 7 million reasons he will probably be protected. They are not going to pay a $7 Million bonus and just as it looks like the hit tool is coming around they give that investment to someone else.

  10. Jefferson Green

    I doubt the Reds current FO leadership will fall for sunk cost as a reason to give AlfRod a spot over another player (whether from within the current organization or through a pick up from another team at some point). They have been making much better decisions than that lately, and as noted above, investment banker types like DW are quite familiar with regularly moving on (usually quickly) from investments that are not paying off.
    I suppose there is some remote chance that the Reds see something in his swing/approach that has been radically improving, but has yet to manifest itself in his numbers; however, this is a guy who was older than average (25) for a prospect at AA, and who needed a BABIP 45 points over his prior career BABIP to get his average up to .286 and his OBP to .325. With his prior career BABIP, his average would have been down around .250 and his OBP under .300, all with zero power. Putrid production.

    • MK

      It was Castelini’s money and he is still there.

      • BK

        So, if they just put AlfRod on the 40-man roster, Mr. C. won’t notice they missed on a $9M investment?

      • Jefferson Green

        BK – great comments on this thread. Yes, this is an example of another decision that indicates this FO is better than previous leadership, and DW (and probably BC) are able to understand that all investments don’t work – just move on quickly.
        And yes, they looked to players being DFA’s and landed one from Tampa for (probably) a song. I appreciate the insights.

  11. MK

    It was Castelini’s money and he is still there.

  12. AirborneJayJay

    The Texas Rangers have left unprotected former University of Kentucky starting pitcher Kyle Cody. He was going well until elbow problems sidelined him in 2018. He had TJ surgery in 2018 and missed all of 2019. He is a RHP, 6’7″ and 245. He has a starter’s arsenal. He had a fastball at 95 that touched higher before the surgery.
    Do you think the Reds could hide him in the bullpen for 1/2 the season? He has to be on the active roster for some 90 days. I would say his stuff would play up in the pen. He could be like Lorenzen out of the pen if his stuff plays up some. He also would be under the direct tutelage of pitching coach Derek Johnson for a whole season. This move would be more as a move for 2021 and later as a starting pitcher. But he could be useful in 2020 out of the pen if used properly. He could always go back to AAA as a starter to start the 2021 season or he could win a spot in the rotation for 2021. Cody, added to with Greene and Lodolo, make for a very intriguing trio after this 2020 season.
    The Reds aren’t really in a position to take on a Rule 5 player, but this could be just the spot to do it. With an eye towards the 2021 and beyond rotation too of course. The Reds could very well lose both Bauer and DeSclafani after this coming season.
    Cody could be a steal for the Reds.
    A semi-scouting report from just before his TJ surgery:

    https://nolanwritin.com/2018/05/31/texas-rangers-prospect-radar-kyle-cody/