The Cincinnati Reds got the 9-game home stand off to a great start, with a 6-3 win over the Chicago Cubs. It was a team victory, with excellent starting pitching by Sonny Gray, great relief pitching by Michael Lorenzen, and ample run support by the offense. That’s a winning recipe.

The Reds are 5-2 against the Cubs this year. The Reds are 5-2 against the Cubs this year. The Reds are 5-2 against the Cubs this year.

Aspiration: A series sweep puts the Reds 3.5 games behind the Cubs.

Reds 6 – Cubs 3 | Game 79 of 162

Box Score | Win Probability | Exit Velocity | Pitch Velocity

Run Prevention

In his 16th start for the Reds, Sonny Gray was strictly business, going 6.1 innings on 98 pitches. He dominated the Cubs the first two times through their lineup. The third time through, he gave up several balls to the warning track before surrendering a 2-run, 420-foot homer to Jason Heyward with one out in the sixth. Gray struck out six and walked one, Kris Bryant in his third at bat. The lead run on Heyward’s homer came on a swinging bunt (63 mph EV) by Javier Baez. 

So far, Gray has vindicated the Reds confidence they had in signing him to a 3-year extension through the 2020 season. Gray’s strikeout rate (26.7%) is well above league average of 22.8%. Gray’s ground ball rate (55.9%) is the highest of his career and well above league average. Before tonight, Gray’s ERA was 4.03 (now down to 3.94). But it’s important to remember the run environment context. League average ERA is 4.47. So Gray has pitched 10% better than average. Adjusting for fielding and luck, Gray has been about 20% better than MLB average.

Gray got the first five outs of the game on strikeouts, mainly thanks to his curveball. Anthony Rizzo swung at a curve in the first inning that bounced in front of home plate.

Gray’s curve has a 7.2 in horizontal and 3 inch vertical break. That’s due in large part to his spin rate of 2910 rpm, which is in the top 5% of all baseball. Here’s a movement grid of curveballs for all starting pitchers. The red arrow points to Sonny Gray. The farther into the bottom right corner, the better.

David Hernandez relieved Gray in the seventh. He gave up an extra-base hit down the left field corner that somehow got played into a triple. The extra base cost the Reds a run when Albert Almora hit a sacrifice fly.

Amir Garrett pitched the 8th. After getting Middletown’s Kyle Schwarber to line out, he walked Kris Bryant and hit Anthony Rizzo. David Bell lifted Garrett for Michael Lorenzen. The score was 6-3 with the tying run at the plate.

Lorenzen’s job wasn’t easy. He had to face Javier Baez and Willson Contreras, two 2019 All-Star starters. Lorenzen needed just five pitches – four fastballs and one slider – to induce two routine ground balls and the Reds were out of trouble.

Lorenzen came on to finish the game in the 9th. Jason Heyward led off the ninth with a 346-foot line drive to right field that Yasiel Puig leapt up to make a great catch before crashing into the wall. Kinda felt sorry for the wall on that one.

Lorenzen struck out Addison Russell and Victor Caratini to end the game.

Lorenzen threw his change-up five times, for four swings and misses. Matt Wilkes wrote about the importance of Michael Lorenzen adding an off-speed pitch to his portfolio this year.

“Rather than relying on the slider with two strikes, he’s throwing it early in counts. Meanwhile, he has developed a better putaway pitch: the changeup. It was a strong swing-and-miss pitch for Lorenzen last year (36.6% whiff rate), but he barely threw it (7.4%). He’s using it more in 2019 (16.5%), and it’s getting whiffs nearly half the time batters swing at it. Here’s the league leaderboard in whiff% among all pitchers who’ve gotten swings on at least 50 changeups:

    1. Tommy Kahnle (Yankees): 54.0%
    2. Brandon Brennan (Mariners): 52.9%
    3. Luis Castillo (Reds): 50.5%
    4. Raisel Iglesias (Reds): 48.7%
    5. Michael Lorenzen (Reds): 48.2%”

Indeed. Three saves for Lorenzen in the last three opportunities.

Run Production

Joey Votto had four hits tonight, including number 1800 for his career. The 35-year-old also swiped second base. Hit 1800 drove in Nick Senzel. 

He walked in his fifth plate appearance to make it a perfect Joey Votto night.

The Reds got to Cubs starter Cole Hamels in the first inning for a run and it could have been more if Jason Heyward hadn’t made a great play on a line drive in the RCF gap from Nick Senzel. Hamels left the game before throwing a pitch in the second inning due to injury. Joey Votto singled, Eugenio Suarez drew a walk, Yasiel Puig lined a single to right field, loading the bases. Jose Iglesias hit a routine double-play ground ball, but Puig barreled down the base line and was on top of Cubs 2b Addison Russell. Russell couldn’t make the throw to first. A run scored. 

Philip Ervin greeted Mike Montgomery, who came on to pitch for Hamels, with a 385-foot home run, making the score 2-0.

Later, Ervin doubled to right center. The double was a harder-hit ball than his home run (99.5 mph vs. 103.7 mph). With two more games against LH starting pitchers, you wonder if Ervin will get those starts in LF. Other options include Jose Peraza and Jesse Winker.

Nick Senzel had a good night at the plate, with a double and a walk. The double drove in two runs in the 4-run 4th inning. Senzel did make a base running mistake. He walked, then stole second. But on a line drive by Votto into centerfield, Senzel waited to see if the ball fell in for a hit despite there being two outs. It cost the Reds a run.

We might have seen a couple signs that Eugenio Suarez is working out of his slump (.242/.326/.457). He walked twice, to go with two walks in the first game in Anaheim. He also had two hard-hit balls (96.6 mph and 100.3 mph).

Tucker Barnhart Injury Update

From Bobby Nightengale of the Cincinnati Enquirer:

What’s Next?

The Reds (37-42) play the stupid Cubs (44-38) again on Saturday. Game time is 4:10 p.m. Forecast temperature for the first pitch is 89º. The starting pitching matchup features Luis Castillo and Jose Quintana (L). 

36 Responses

  1. matt hendley

    Great win by the Reds. Even though it wasn’t the reds doing, they also took advantage of the Hamells injury.

    Whichever Luis Castillo that shows up for the Game tomorow will decide if we go into sunday with a series sweep on the line.

  2. Sliotar

    Whoa, whoa.
    Let’s hold the horses on assigning a loss to tomorrow’s game, especially with Castillo (!!!) going.

    Reds are 5-2 vs. Cubs this season.

    4 games in a row scoring at least 6 runs vs. Chicago.

    Might just be a year where the Reds have their number.

    • Steve Mancuso

      Yeah, I had fixed that. Shouldn’t rely on Thom for even the most basic facts without double-checking.

      • Sliotar

        It is funny the contrast between TV crews.

        “5 out of 7″ was Len Kasper’s first words after the final out was recorded.

        Kasper and Deshaies spent the 8th and 9th innings discussing bullpen usage….the Reds’ usage by Bell. Great discussion.

        I know there are Thom fans in this crowd it sure seems to me he just shows up and goes through the motions most nights….”Middletown.”

      • vegastypo

        Something I found odd between the Reds TV and radio crews also: While I had the TV audio feed on, I heard Thom say that the Cubs announced that Hamels left with pain in his side, no elaborating beyond that, lat or oblique or whatever ….. But when I fled from Thom to the radio feed, got tired of hearing him talk about hats with feathers in them, Marty said a few times that the Cubs had not given an update on Hamels.

      • Scott C

        Loved the win tonight but it was sure nice the two games in Anaheim not having to listen to Thom. There are times I don’t believe he is even watching the game, let alone preparing for it beforehand. Just coasting on his dad’s coattails.

  3. CFD3000

    Nice team win for the Reds, especially against the Cubs, especially with Hamels on the mound to start (he’s been their stud until tonight but hope he’s not badly hurt), especially to stop a four game skid, and especially to start this important home stand. Welcome back Scooter – who looked fine diving into first base. My only complaint is that Barnhart is out, perhaps for a month. I’d much rather have Tucker healthy and Peraza in Louisville. Still a great game for the Reds. Can’t wait for tomorrow and Castillo’s turn. Go Reds!

  4. Jreis

    This is Phil Ervin’s world and we are just living in it. The every day left field position is his if he wants it. The question is does he want it?

    Also the more I watch Puig the more I want to keep this guy around. He reminds me so much of Dave Parker. Not a dirty player but a physical player for sure

    • Curt

      Dodgers need relievers, maybe we could get Downs or Gray back for Iggy? Ha!

    • Big Ed

      Winker’s splits against RH pitching are much better than Ervin’s. Ervin is faster and likely a better fielder, but he did play a double into a triple last night. (The bounce was odd, and the replays I saw didn’t show where Ervin started and exactly how he played it.)

      I do hope that they let Ervin start the other 2 games in this series. He has generally produced with regular playing time.

      I also like Puig. I can see them going either way with him, either extending him or trading him in late July.

      • Jim Walker

        PE was either slow to get over or was positioned well toward left center on the p;ay. Guess it is on the shift master not PE if it was the latter. And the ball did seem to get caught under the wall and just die like they do sometimes.

      • Scott C

        Good reply Big Ed. Winker is certainly not shabby at the plate. Ervin may well be better against LH pitching. But this weekend is an anomaly in as far as seeing 3 straight LH starters.

      • daytonnati

        Ervin to center. Winker and Puig in the corners. Senzel to second base.

    • RojoBenjy

      You know i’m a fan of his. Hope he can get the opportunities and then leverage them for success!

  5. Cyrus

    The Reds have 83 games left. Based on the standings thru tonight, the Reds play 10 games against teams with poorer records, 38 versus teams in 1st or 2nd place in their division and 64 matchups with teams at or above .500. If you are doing the hidden math here, that leaves 9 games with the Pirates who are below .500 but have a better record than us.

    The Cards may have lost their best player for a while to a fluke finger injury: Ozuna.

  6. Big Ed

    You would think that we (I) would learn to quit writing Joey Votto off after a slow start.

    • Mike Adams

      Don’t be so hard on yourself, Big Ed.
      I am SO glad he is back.
      But, that may be how his eventual decline will manifest itself.
      Longer and longer slow starts until September comes around and he is not back to his old self.
      Hope it never happens but growing old happens to all and is not for cowards, baseball player or not.

      • daytonnati

        Maybe he should start playing winter ball 🙂

    • greenmtred

      Look at it as practicing for it when it actually happens, Big Ed. It’s great to see him hitting again. Do we think that he figured out the problem and changed his approach? Brantley seems to–he noted that the flat swing is supplanting the uppercut. I’ll confess that I haven’t noticed.

    • VaRedsFan

      unfortunately 2 months of poor Votto has once again put the Reds into the cellar of the division

      • Lwblogger2

        Yes, it’s mostly Votto’s fault. I mean, he’s the leader of the offense and his struggles obviously made others struggle.


        Votto’s slow start certainly didn’t help matters but to point at it as the reason the Reds are bad? Come on.

  7. Reddawg12

    Nothing better than seeing all those Cubs fans at GABP go home mad.

    • Mason Red

      Nothing worse than seeing them there in the first place. Too many tickets available so it’s easy pickings for Cubs fans. Put a quarter team on the field and that won’t happen at least to that degree.

      • RojoBenjy

        Hey Cubs fans—thanks for the money!
        Love, Big Bob

  8. Pete

    Great to see JV and Puig increase their trade value and Ervin produce when given the opportunity. I can see no reason for Ervin to not get the nod the next two games but I suspect Peraza will at least get 1 start in LF this weekend.

    Casali’s opportunity to latch on to the full-time gig.

    • RojoBenjy

      We can see no reason Ervin shouldn’t start. But somehow the manager finds reasons. The same reasoning used to justify Jose9 getting playing time.

      • Rich H

        No reason except that Winker, Senzel, and Puig have been better hitters for literally their entire careers…

      • Pete

        Rich H. – not really. Career MLB, OPS versus LHP:

        Ervin: .833
        Winker: .566

        When, and if they trade Puig, I’d like to see an outfield of Winker-Senzel-Ervin.

  9. old-school

    Very good baseball game.

    Much has been made of who the Reds are and how they cant get to .500 and rightly so. However, The Reds are 24-24 since Nick Senzel was added to the offense. What can the Reds offense do with both Senzel and Gennett in the lineup and Votto/Suarez/Puig playing at good levels. What can the offense do with Winker or Ervin in the lineup everyday?

    2019 is shaping up to be a historic year for competitiveness in the NL. The Dodgers will win 100. Most projection systems have the Braves at 90, but that’s it. It’s possible (2) wildcard teams could get in with 85 wins. The Nationals are getting hot but are still only 41-40. The Phillies are starting to look like the Brewers a few games over .500. The Cardinals have lost 4 in a row and sit at .500 and have lost Ozuna. The Cubs are struggling against the……….Reds? The Reds have survived 3 West Coast road trips. That’s 5 under baseball right there every year before the season starts. The Brewers, Cards and Cubs play each other 30+ times the second half of the season. The NL central is not going to separate itself nor will the NL East. The Reds plays 16 of their next 21 against the Cubs, Brewers, and Cards.

    The ole’ Redlegs could really help create an NL Central mess with some good baseball the next few weeks.

  10. TR

    The Reds pitching is the positive of this season with the Bell/Johnson duo getting it done. I would like see R. Iglesias used where needed by joining the closer by committee group along with Lorenzen, Garrett, Bowman, Hernandez and perhaps others. If this doesn’t work for Iglesias, then he should be included in a trade. It’s time to move on from this fixed closer position with emphasis on the saver stat.

    • RojoBenjy

      It seems that Raisel has already styled himself as a square peg. I agree time to move him if he won’t join the team philosophy.

  11. Shchi Cossack

    Late to the party, but the Youngest Cossack has his state track meet at Jesse Owens Stadium this weekend (a silver medal in his 4X100 meter relay and a gold medal in his 100 meter dash so far!). Just a little nit pick, the Reds signed Gray to a 3-year extension through 2022 (not 2020) with a club option for 2023.

    Joey Votto now slashing .304/.402/.532/.934 for June with a .228 ISO. For the season, he now sports a 102 OPS+. He’s not there yet, but he’s surging and a surging Joey Votto is a magnificent sight to behold.

  12. Shchi Cossack

    With Tucker on the self for an extended time, a full 40-man roster and Barnhart & Casali the only 2 catchers on the 40-man roster, we ay get a look at Farmer behind the dish when Casali needs a break during the dog days of summer descending upon us.

    • Old-school


      Doesn’t that also mean Farmer is a catcher only now for a few weeks ? Can’t pinch hit in the 6 th or start in LF as needed for catching in case Casali gets knicked up in a game.