If you listened to the most recent episode of the Redleg Nation Radio podcast, you were introduced to RNR Madness. As you might expect, it’s a 68-team tournament to name the most valuable player in Reds history. Your votes are going to determine the winner. Let’s get this thing started!

Every week until we crown a champion, you will have the opportunity to vote for who wins each matchup. The polls will open each Sunday at 8:00 pm, and will remain open for precisely three days. Remember that you are voting for “Most Valuable Red.” The definition of “valuable” is open to interpretation and completely up to you. Feel free to leave comments about any particular aspect of the voting, or any individual matchup, and we may discuss it on the podcast.

Here’s the bracket:

Today, we are opening up the polls for the First Four and the Round of 64. The First Four contains eight #16 seeds, all vying for the opportunity to face off against a #1 seed in the Round of 64. Here are the contestants:

First Four -- Crosley Region

  • 16 Scott Williamson (83%, 331 Votes)
  • 16 Corey Patterson (17%, 67 Votes)

Total Voters: 398

Loading ... Loading ...

First Four -- Riverfront Region

  • 16 Dave Parker (93%, 373 Votes)
  • 16 Wayne Krenchicki (7%, 27 Votes)

Total Voters: 400

Loading ... Loading ...

First Four -- Great American Region

  • 16 Pedro Borbon (77%, 312 Votes)
  • 16 Lisalverto Bonilla (23%, 91 Votes)

Total Voters: 403

Loading ... Loading ...

First Four -- Palace of the Fans Region

  • 16 Tom Browning (96%, 395 Votes)
  • 16 Skip Schumaker (4%, 17 Votes)

Total Voters: 412

Loading ... Loading ...

Now we will address the Round of 64 matchups, first in the Crosley Region. For research purposes: Johnny Bench | Scott Williamson | Corey Patterson | Cy Seymour | Pete Donohue | Jim Maloney | Chris Sabo | Bid McPhee | Bronson Arroyo | Brandon Phillips | Jake Beckley | Edd Roush | Eugenio Suarez | Joe Nuxhall | John Reilly | Vada Pinson | Rob Dibble

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 1/16

  • 1 Johnny Bench (100%, 423 Votes)
  • 16 Williamson/Patterson (0%, 0 Votes)

Total Voters: 423

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 8/9

  • 8 Cy Seymour (70%, 252 Votes)
  • 9 Pete Donohue (30%, 108 Votes)

Total Voters: 360

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 5/12

  • 5 Jim Maloney (51%, 207 Votes)
  • 12 Chris Sabo (49%, 201 Votes)

Total Voters: 408

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 4/13

  • 13 Bronson Arroyo (51%, 207 Votes)
  • 4 Bid McPhee (49%, 196 Votes)

Total Voters: 403

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 6/11

  • 6 Brandon Phillips (94%, 384 Votes)
  • 11 Jake Beckley (6%, 23 Votes)

Total Voters: 407

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 3/14

  • 3 Edd Roush (62%, 248 Votes)
  • 14 Eugenio Suarez (38%, 152 Votes)

Total Voters: 400

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 7/10

  • 7 Joe Nuxhall (95%, 385 Votes)
  • 10 John Reilly (5%, 19 Votes)

Total Voters: 404

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Crosley Region 2/15

  • 2 Vada Pinson (82%, 329 Votes)
  • 15 Rob Dibble (18%, 74 Votes)

Total Voters: 403

Loading ... Loading ...

Now, the Riverfront Region:

Frank Robinson | Dave Parker | Wayne Krenchicki | Johnny Vander Meer | Frank McCormick | Dave Concepcion | Aroldis Chapman | Eric Davis | Bob Purkey | Dolf Luque | Tony Mullane | Heinie Groh | Lee May | Ewell Blackwell | Adam Dunn | Tony Perez | Kal Daniels

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 1/16

  • 1 Frank Robinson (98%, 391 Votes)
  • 16 Parker/Krenchicki (2%, 10 Votes)

Total Voters: 401

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 8/9

  • 8 Johnny Vander Meer (82%, 318 Votes)
  • 9 Frank McCormick (18%, 69 Votes)

Total Voters: 387

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 5/12

  • 5 Dave Concepcion (89%, 355 Votes)
  • 12 Aroldis Chapman (11%, 46 Votes)

Total Voters: 401

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 4/13

  • 4 Eric Davis (99%, 388 Votes)
  • 13 Bob Purkey (1%, 2 Votes)

Total Voters: 390

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 6/11

  • 6 Dolf Luque (78%, 273 Votes)
  • 11 Tony Mullane (22%, 79 Votes)

Total Voters: 352

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 3/14

  • 3 Heinie Groh (57%, 208 Votes)
  • 14 Lee May (43%, 156 Votes)

Total Voters: 364

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 7/10

  • 10 Adam Dunn (62%, 238 Votes)
  • 7 Ewell Blackwell (38%, 148 Votes)

Total Voters: 386

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Riverfront Region 2/15

  • 2 Tony Perez (98%, 383 Votes)
  • 15 Kal Daniels (2%, 8 Votes)

Total Voters: 391

Loading ... Loading ...

Next up, the Great American Region:
Joe Morgan | Pedro Borbon | Lisalverto Bonilla | Jim O’Toole | Reggie Sanders | Ernie Lombardi | Kevin Mitchell | Jose Rijo | John Franco | Lonny Frey | Aaron Harang | Eppa Rixey | Don Gullett | Gary Nolan | Ken Griffey | Joey Votto | Sean Casey

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 1/16

  • 1 Joe Morgan (99%, 378 Votes)
  • 16 Borbon/Lisalverto! (1%, 5 Votes)

Total Voters: 383

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 8/9

  • 9 Reggie Sanders (65%, 243 Votes)
  • 8 Jim O'Toole (35%, 132 Votes)

Total Voters: 375

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 5/12

  • 5 Ernie Lombardi (83%, 308 Votes)
  • 12 Kevin Mitchell (17%, 61 Votes)

Total Voters: 369

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 4/13

  • 4 Jose Rijo (96%, 368 Votes)
  • 13 John Franco (4%, 14 Votes)

Total Voters: 382

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 6/11

  • 11 Aaron Harang (67%, 246 Votes)
  • 6 Lonny Frey (33%, 123 Votes)

Total Voters: 369

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 3/14

  • 3 Eppa Rixey (59%, 215 Votes)
  • 14 Don Gullett (41%, 150 Votes)

Total Voters: 365

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 7/10

  • 10 Ken Griffey (69%, 261 Votes)
  • 7 Gary Nolan (31%, 118 Votes)

Total Voters: 379

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Great American Region 2/15

  • 2 Joey Votto (97%, 380 Votes)
  • 15 Sean Casey (3%, 12 Votes)

Total Voters: 392

Loading ... Loading ...

Finally, the Palace of the Fans Region:
Pete Rose | Tom Browning | Skip Schumaker | Bucky Walters | Ted Kluszewski | Johnny Cueto | Frank Dwyer | Paul Derringer | Tom Seaver | Noodles Hahn | Red Lucas | George Foster | Ken Griffey Jr. | Mario Soto | Ival Goodman | Barry Larkin | Jay Bruce

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 1/16

  • 1 Pete Rose (90%, 350 Votes)
  • 16 Browning/Schumaker (10%, 39 Votes)

Total Voters: 389

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 8/9

  • 9 Ted Kluszewski (83%, 315 Votes)
  • 8 Bucky Walters (17%, 64 Votes)

Total Voters: 379

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 5/12

  • 5 Johnny Cueto (99%, 383 Votes)
  • 12 Frank Dwyer (1%, 5 Votes)

Total Voters: 388

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 4/13

  • 13 Tom Seaver (62%, 232 Votes)
  • 4 Paul Derringer (38%, 144 Votes)

Total Voters: 376

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 6/11

  • 6 Noodles Hahn (91%, 325 Votes)
  • 11 Red Lucas (9%, 33 Votes)

Total Voters: 358

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 3/14

  • 3 George Foster (71%, 276 Votes)
  • 14 Ken Griffey Jr. (29%, 114 Votes)

Total Voters: 390

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 7/10

  • 7 Mario Soto (99%, 374 Votes)
  • 10 Ival Goodman (1%, 3 Votes)

Total Voters: 377

Loading ... Loading ...

Round of 64 -- Palace of the Fans Region 2/15

  • 2 Barry Larkin (97%, 378 Votes)
  • 15 Jay Bruce (3%, 11 Votes)

Total Voters: 389

Loading ... Loading ...

Winners will be discussed on the next episode of the podcast, and we’ll have Round of 32 voting next week.

14 Responses

  1. CFD3000

    You know the franchise has had some terrific players when the 2 seeds include two Hall of Famers (Larkin and Perez) and one future Hall of Framer (Votto). This is great fun but I fear some recent-ness bias will creep in. Bid McPhee and Ed Roush were fantastic players. Too bad nobody remembers them…

    Finally, I’m disappointed that there’s no Billy Hamilton / Billy Hamilton play-in. I realize you have an unrequited Lisalverto crush Chad, but you dropped the ball on that one. Borbon will crush Bonilla and you’ll wish you had included the Hamilton’s.

    Reply
    • CFD3000

      *oops. Votto will be in Cooperstown, not wherever they enshrine painting restorers…

      Reply
    • Colorado Red

      Pedro Borbon, The Hawk, part of the RRM.
      Gotta move on in the play in round.

      Reply
    • Chad Dotson

      Oooh, you’re right. I missed the boat on that one!

      Reply
  2. gusnwally

    The recency bias shows up the most in the Seaver, Derringer vote. Derringer with 4 2o win seasons and a 19 game season. He and Walters the studs of the 2 World Series teams. So happy to see Big Klu do so well.

    Reply
  3. gusnwally

    The other questionable vote would be Vander Meer over the great Frank Mccormick. A 500 pitcher with 2 famous games over a consistent 300 hitter and league MVP. But this is sorta fun, glad to play along.

    Reply
    • Matt Wilkes

      It’s a shame how little love Bucky Walters is getting too. There’s an argument for him as the best pitcher in Reds history.

      Reply
  4. ARedsFan11

    your first pairing should void this whole bracket… you say a rookie of the year is the same seed as a man who hit .205 for one year with the Reds?

    Reply
    • Amarillo

      No, each of the 16 matchups has an actual 16 seed, and a joke player.

      Reply
  5. Ed

    I have a hard time with the really old players and the silly stats that they put up. There are some ridiculous amounts of complete games for the pitchers.

    Reply
  6. Richard Fitch

    I’ll just say this about Gary Nolan. He literally gave his right arm to the Cincinnati Reds. They didn’t believe him when he complained of the pain. They didn’t take care of him properly. Yet, he went out there and pitched in the kind of agony few could comprehend.

    Should have moved on to the next round.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.