I’d start looking for tickets. Or at least broadcast availability.

Thursday the Reds open up a four-game home stand against the St. Louis Cardinals. But the night to circle on your calendar is 24 hours later, Friday, April 13. Game time is 6:40 p.m. The forecast is for a high of 77º a low of 59º and a chance of Nick Senzel.

The club hasn’t announced it yet, but hints abound that the Reds may call up their top prospect for the last three games of the weekend series.

Nick Senzel is playing third base tonight for the Louisville Bats, just as C. Trent Rosecrans reported this morning that he’d been told. April 13 happens to be the date minor league players can be promoted in the 2018 season and not accrue a full year of service time.

What’s the significance of Nick Senzel playing third base? After all, he played that position all through 2017. Eugenio Suarez’s fractured right thumb, that’s the significance. Senzel has been at second base this week for the Bats, and before that played shortstop for much of spring training.

The Reds haven’t commented on the severity of Suarez’s injury. But based on DL time served by major league players with fractured thumbs the past two seasons, Suarez could be back any time from two weeks to three months. Six-to-eight weeks would be a best guess absent an official statement. That’s late May, early June, for Suarez to return.

Now juxtapose that estimate with major league labor law surrounding Super Two arbitration status. The safe timing for holding players in AAA to avoid the S2 cutoff is early- to mid-June. So if the Reds were planning to hold Nick Senzel until he’d cleared the Super Two cutoff, Eugenio Suarez would likely be back playing third base by then.

So, the club moving the 22-year-old Senzel to 3B right now means the Reds don’t intend to wait until June to call up their top prospect. And if they don’t wait until June, there’s no point in waiting any longer than April 13, this Friday, against the St. Louis Cardinals.

What do we think of calling up Nick Senzel this soon, if that’s what happens?

Here’s the case against it: Nick Senzel had 235 plate appearances in AA and has only 17 PA’s in AAA. In those 17 at bats, he’s hitting .235 with no walks and one extra-base hit. Giving Senzel two months to build confidence hitting AAA pitching is the time-tested way to develop a player, even great ones. By comparison, Joey Votto had 592 plate appearances in AAA. Kris Bryant of the Cubs had 330 PAs in AAA.

Eugenio Suarez will be the Reds 3B for the long haul. The Reds aren’t going to sign a 7-year contract with a player who hasn’t succeeded at the position they intend to play him. Given that, Senzel should keep playing and learning middle infield since that’s his long-term future for the Reds, either at SS or 2B. There’s no short-term benefit, either wins and losses or at the ticket booth, worth slowing down Senzel’s development at his eventual position. Delaying Senzel’s arrival until June would allow the Reds to give Alex Blandino (25) a serious look by playing him most nights at third base.

Here’s the case for it: Senzel is the best healthy third baseman in the organization. With Suarez and Scott Schebler out of the Reds lineup, Senzel’s bat – not Alex Blandino’s bat – is needed for offense. Bryce Harper had 84 plate appearances in AAA. Mike Trout had 93. Dansby Swanson had just 45.

Nick Senzel has demonstrated an ability to switch infield positions, so if he plays 3B for Suarez now, he can move over to SS or 2B when the Reds third baseman returns. Or, there’s the way-outside chance the Reds intend to have Suarez move back to shortstop. And, if Senzel’s call up happens to add excitement (and ticket sales) to a team off to a 2-7 start, that’s a plus for fans and the organization. Even Mom-and-Pop produce stands appreciate more business.

Tapping the brakes is never fun. But Nick Senzel playing third tonight might not mean anything more than just a night off for the Bats other third baseman. And even if they do intend to call Senzel up before the Super Two cutoff, the front office could choose any date between this Friday and Suarez’s return to call Senzel up and give him playing time at third. There might even be good developmental reason to wait a couple weeks.

That said, I’ve already started thinking about where I’m gonna be at 6:40 p.m. this Friday.

14 Responses

  1. doofus

    This franchise needs to do something other than introducing a new bobblehead, building a new “Beer” bar or bottom-feeding for relievers to show the fans the organization has a pulse. Senzel is one answer. It shows the fans they have faith in who they have drafted. And, I believe that Senzel will be capable of succeeding at the major league level.

  2. doofus

    If, Senzel is brought up on Friday, he has to start.

  3. Old-school

    It doesn’t make sense for Senzel to play shortstop all spring training…..then move him to 2b for 3 weeks….then back to his natural 3b for 8 weeks in mlb and then back to where??? 2b at AAA….SS @ mlb?

    Bring Suarez back at SS and let Senzel play a season at 3b. See how it goes.

    • Jim Walker

      But doesn’t the way Senzel is being moved around just reflect the same lack of focus and direction we keep seeing in the development of the young pitching?

      • David

        Senzel was playing 2nd and Blandino was actually playing SS at AAA. Blandino has little experience at SS, and I think they were thinking of making him the Ute player. 2nd, SS, 3rd.

        Scooter maybe plays second, or outfield, and Senzel slides over to 2nd, and he is certainly a better fielder at 2nd base than Scooter.
        Peraza still deserves at least part of the season to prove himself. He actually looks better at the plate the last few days. Give these guys some time to actually prove or disprove themselves.

      • Indy Red Man

        Blandino was playing 3B at AAA actually.

      • doofus

        For what it’s worth…MILB has Blandino only playing 3B at Louisville so far. Trahan was at SS.

  4. David

    Eugenio has added some weight since he last played shortstop. His hands, arm and reflexes are fine, but I don’t know if he can move that well at SS now. Eugenio returns healthy and hand strong, and Nick slides over to …..2nd or SS for the rest of the season. Or plays in the outfield. Or something. (What if he struggles hitting in the ML?)

    Kris Bryant was the comp for Nick Senzel, but Kris ONLY played in AAA, and never in the lower minors. Nick is probably as ready as he will ever be. And sure, 2 more months in AAA would be something for him to get his feet under him, so to speak. And Super 2 arb status, and all that.
    But really, is he going to actually learn something he doesn’t know in 2 months?

    There are a lot of players that skipped AAA altogether. Reggie Sanders comes to mind.

    • doofus

      I thought Suarez was more cut coming out of ST. I think he can handle SS.

  5. doofus

    FYI, Finnegan’s numbers in last night’s L’Ville game were bad.

    • David

      Another rehab start before he comes up, please. Probably still getting his arm strength up, plus, it has been cold. The cold can effect how well somebody grips the ball and how well they get loose.

      • doofus

        Opposition’s starter, 30 year old Adam Wilk had no problems with the 48 degree weather. He posted good numbers over 5.1 innings. Usually us old guys have a tougher time with the cold weather than youngsters like Finnegan. I think Finnegan will eventually find himself a reliever, and a good one.

  6. Eric the Red

    Calling him up to play 3B now would be consistent with delaying the rebuild because of the All Star Game, trading Chapman for nothing in a panic, putting guys in the bullpen instead of letting them learn how to start so we can lose 89 games instead of 90, etc. In other words, this move brought to you by Bob Castellini and the Reds marketing department….

  7. TurboBuckeye

    Bringing up Senzel this early does smack a bit of desperation–give the fannies SOMETHING to believe in.