2017 Reds

Again, Joey Votto has not been traded (and is unlikely to be)

We reported earlier this off-season that Joey Votto was not traded to the Toronto Blue Jays. We can now report that Votto still hasn’t been traded, and Reds GM Dick Williams isn’t particularly keen to deal the club’s first baseman:

“I certainly haven’t had any discussions with him about [waiving the no-trade],” Reds general manager Dick Williams told MLB Network last week at the General Managers Meetings. “When you have a player of that caliber, there’s always going to be that speculation and the questions out there in the industry. I can just tell you right now, I’m really comfortable with him in our lineup. I’m very happy with the contract we’ve got with him. He performed as well as he has in a long time, in recent years. I see him being at the center of our lineup and a guy we could really build around.”

Yes, I can see that too. Joey Votto continues to be an elite hitter, one of the best in the majors. As we discussed on the latest podcast (go listen, and subscribe!), Votto was completely robbed of a 2016 Silver Slugger award, despite being clearly the best-hitting first baseman in the National League. Can you believe that Votto has never won a Silver Slugger? It’s ludicrous.

Which once again proves my theory: Germans Love David Hasselhoff.

moransNo wait, that’s a different theory. It all comes back to my thesis that Joey Votto — perhaps the best Reds hitter of all time — is underrated and underpaid. Dick Williams seems to appreciate Votto’s value to the Reds lineup, but so does everyone with a brain — even if reasonable people can disagree on the underrated and underpaid part of that equation. The guy can flat out hit, and he’s showing few signs of slowing down.

Look, I’m a sentimental guy (I didn’t want the Reds to trade Jay Bruce, remember) but I’m also sentimental about players who do the things that help my team score runs. I want Joey Votto to be the main guy in the middle of the next good Reds team’s lineup. (Or maybe that guy will be Nick Senzel. I wouldn’t mind seeing Votto be the second-best hitter on the team.) Plus, there’s this, according to Mark Sheldon:

Although Votto is not known as a textbook clubhouse leader, his work ethic influenced the young clubhouse positively. He was also willing to help some players with their hitting, including Billy Hamilton. All signs are pointing to him continuing to contribute and lead for Cincinnati in 2017, and beyond.

So no, Joey Votto has not been traded. And that’s a good thing.

Disclaimer: (Don’t construe this, however, as a statement that I consider Votto untouchable in trade talks. If someone wants to give the Reds good value in return, there shouldn’t be anyone in the organization that is untouchable. Except perhaps Billy Hamilton, of course.)

9 thoughts on “Again, Joey Votto has not been traded (and is unlikely to be)

  1. As salaries continue to climb and production seems to fade for many players not long after they sign a big long term contract (see Fielder, Prince, Hamilton, Josh and many others) Joey Votto continues to hit at an elite level. Yup, I said it. We all hope the Reds are building a solid lineup for the future, but without Votto in the middle it would be just a nice expirment. The Cubs will build around Bryant, Rizzo, and probably Schwarber, and they make guys like Fowler, Russell, Zobrist and Heyward look great as complementary bats. The Reds need Votto and a couple more of Hamilton, Senzel, Schebler, Duvall, Winker, Suarez, Herrera and Peraza to be that core, with the rest contributing as complementary pieces. But without Votto it’s more a wish and a prayer than a real plan. Keep Joey Votto.

    • +1000. This team without Votto is 5 players away on offense alone. With Votto, I think Senzel and Winker could be enough.

  2. Agreed. Money is not what’s preventing this team from making the playoffs, it’s identifying talent.

  3. Chad….does your wife know about this “thing” you have for Billy Hamilton.. ?

  4. I think that the FO should revisit trade talks with Toronto. DW should aim high and go for a JV for Sanchez, Osuna, Tellez and Gurriel deal. That takes care of our 5th starter, 3rd piece to pair with Iglesias and Lorenzen to form “Nasty Boys 2”, future 1st baseman as he should start the year in Louisville and the 6th ranked international FA. That would give us the 5th, 6th and 7th ranked international FAs in our organization. Gurriel is an IF/OF, so he would fit nicely in Pensacola as the starting LF. Along with Aquino, they would form an exciting pair of corner OFs in the Southern League. If he’s better than that, playing somewhere at Louisville. I’d hate to see JV leave, but if we could get a haul like that, the FO has to consider making the trade.

  5. What is the goal for trading Votto? If we score big we get a potential MVP candidate in the middle of our lineup for years to come. Isn’t that what we already have. Votto is irreplaceable for one guy with the exception of 10 or so players in the game. When you include multiple players you must also include the value of the players playing that position with Votto. How about we trade some idiot our top AA talent for there Joey Votto.

Comments are closed.