For the rest of the summer, I will be spending my time in Europe, which thankfully limits my exposure to the Reds bullpen. However, by nature of the transitive property, my exposure to my other true love–college baseball, specifically Vanderbilt college baseball–is also greatly diminished. But this column is not meant to bemoan my personal hardships.

As we all know, the Reds have the wonderful fortune of the second pick in the 2016 draft (and the 35th overall pick as part of the competitive balance round A). While it is entirely likely the Reds will take a high schooler with that pick (you know, upside and all that), it is possible a seasoned college man will be the choice. Of all the first round picks last year (42 in total), 20 were college players and 14 of those were showcased in the tournament, including all of the top three picks.

Despite none of the Reds projected picks (Jason Groome, Nick Senzel, Kyle Lewis) actually playing in the tourney, that shouldn’t limit any advanced fan scouting. The Reds could pull a fast one on us…or maybe not, but there is always the 35th pick. With that said, here’s a bit of primer for the faces to watch in the NCAA DI Baseball Championship starting this afternoon. Who knows, maybe one day one will be the face of the Reds?*

*Note: Super duper, ultra-very unlikely.

1st Pick (2nd Overall)


Photo from

AJ Puk (LHP, University of Florida)

6-7, 230 pounds and dirty with the slider, A.J. Puk looks a lot like Pirates super-prospect Tyler Glasnow save one small detail: Puk’s a southpaw. Yet while many consider Puk to be the top prospect in this draft (and is on the Phillies short list), he’s not the clear cut number one.

That’s not because there’s anything particularly wrong with Puk–he did record a 2.88 ERA in 65.2 innings, striking out 90 and drawing comparisons to Chris Sale–but any hard throwing hurler has his injury risk. Also, Major League teams tend to prefer dreaming of what high school studs could become instead of what college stars are. So, the Phillies could very easily go for a high school bat and let Puk fall to the Reds at #2.

In his last start of the season against LSU, Puk went 7.1 innings, giving up two earned runs and striking out seven but taking a no decision. According to the Enquirer’s C. Trent Rosecrans, Puk touched 95 mph with his fastball as late as the eighth inning.

While Puk would certainly be the best available if on the board, taking him could be a knee-jerk reaction to the club’s recent pitching injury troubles. The Reds dreadfully need bats to bolster the aging lineup, and there’s no shortage of young arms in the system.

#1 overall seed Florida takes on Bethune-Cookman tonight at 5 CST in Gainesville.

Corey Ray (OF, Louisville)

It’s no secret the Reds need bats–heck, with Jay Bruce, Zack Cozart, and Adam Duvall all potentially leaving town, the Reds will soon be hard-pressed to get a ball past the dirt. Enter Corey Ray: the junior Louisville right fielder who currently claims a .971 OPS. Ray also leads the Cardinals in home runs with 15 (nearly doubling the next closest mark) and in steals with 39. His sheer athleticism gives him the potential to clean up his defense a bit, but overall, Ray is a solid four-tool prospect with room to improve.

Just recently, Ray was named a semifinalist for the Golden Spikes award, the top honor in college baseball. Prior to the season, there were concerns about Ray’s struggles with making contact, but after posting a respectable 12.8% strikeout rate and 11.7% walk rate, Ray might just be the answer the Reds need in the outfield.

Imagine by mid-2017, the Reds outfield is comprised of Jesse Winker, Billy Hamilton, and Corey Ray. Not awe-inspiring, but not too shabby either. Ray has drawn comparisons to Curtis Granderson, which I believe overstates his power, but a Starling Marte with more plate discipline comp could make sense.

Potentially unrelated but likely super related, Corey Ray’s Twitter handle–@FutureIs_Bright–proves that if the Reds draft him their future too will become bright.

#2 overall seed Louisville will take on Western Michigan tonight at 5 CST.

Buddy Reed (OF, University of Florida)


John Raoux | Associated Press, Photo from the Orlando Sentinel

Before the season, Florida outfielder Buddy Reed looked like an absolute lock to be a top ten draft pick. Now, Baseball Prospectus hasn’t even included him in the top 34 picks of their most recent mock. What happened?

For one, Reed only hit .259/.361/.410, not bad numbers but not impressive when playing for the best in the country. Also, Reed has drawn direct comparisons to Ray all year long, a battle he’s going to lose every time hitting as he did. Having his calling card be his superior defense hurts Reed immensely when compared to the other ridiculous numbers put up by college hitters.

What helps Reed in that department is his speed and switch-hitting ability–sound familiar? MLB Pipeline gave a succinct summary of Reed’s hitting potential:

He does tend to make contact from both sides of the plate, but his setup and approach are inconsistent. Reed has strength, and he should grow into more, though his lack of extenston from the left side could keep him from showing any power that way. A tendency to be tentative at the plate has plagued him, but he was swinging more aggressively as the spring progressed, showing the ability drive the ball more effectively.

Refining of Reed’s approach should help him reach his offensive ceiling.

At the end of the day, the Maryland native and USA Collegiate National team player is still a four plus-tool player, but that fifth missing link is his bat. After this season, it seems that Buddy Reed’s best comp might just be a rich man’s version of the Reds current center fielder. I’m leaving Reed as a potential #2 overall pick because his ceiling is so high, but if the Reds end up with him, it’ll be from the 35th pick, not the second.

2nd Pick (35th Overall)


Brian Westerhold/Four Seam Images, from

Will Craig (1B/3B, Wake Forest)

All three of the following names are unlikely to fall to the Reds at 35, but of the three, Will Craig is the most likely. Wake Forest’s burly first baseman destroyed the ball this season, mashing to the tune of .392/.537/.766. He also–actually, just read that line again. Craig had an OPS of 1.303. He got on base more than half of his at-bats. He made more than a handful of pitchers cry themselves to sleep while their roommate could do nothing but sit there quiet and still.

Craig’s numbers this season have been so ridiculous that he prompted one blog to run an article headlined: “Will Craig is making a mockery of college baseball.” From the piece, which was written in early April:

Now Craig has done the baseball equivalent of breaking Madden. Or he sold his soul. Or maybe he ordered an officially licensed Jobu doll from and sacrificed a whole semi full of live chickens. Whatever he’s done, it’s working to the tune of a .475 batting average. But Craig isn’t sacrificing any power for the sake of average; he leads the NCAA with a .950 slugging percentage. His SLG% alone is higher than any N.C. State player’s OPS! The big donkey’s driven in 41 runs in 24 games (he missed seven due to injury). He’s got a .573 OB% and, despite being a power guy, has walked more times (15) than he’s struck out (12).

All that is well and good, but hone in on that last line. “Has walked more times than he’s struck out…” Craig, breaking the typical power hitter mold, has found a way to appease every type of fan. Long balls for the old folks, walks for the youngsters.

Given all of that, it just doesn’t stand to reason why the human incarnation of Techno Bowl Bo Jackson would slide to the end of the first round. Well, most scouts don’t see Craig adding anything to his game. Even though he’s a complete hitter right now, this is his ceiling. Somehow a 1.300 OPS ceiling is a bad thing. (Even if you adjust by taking half of an average OPS from Craig’s number to mirror the advanced Major League pitching, he’s still sits above .900.)

In truth, Craig’s best comp probably comes in Boston rookie Travis Shaw with the floor of former Boston rookie Will Middlebrooks. Yet, both struck out far more than Craig does so maybe we’ve finally found the unicorn.

Hopefully, College Station Regional three-seed Wake Forest can stick around long enough for all of us to get a good look at Craig. If the Reds can somehow nab him and convince him to play third, the 2017 team starts to look real good.

Wake Forest plays Minnesota today at 3 CST.

Bryan Reynolds (OF, Vanderbilt)

Quick story: I played against Bryan Reynolds my junior year of high school. I have absolutely no recollection of how he played in that game nor those it matter, but he did sport a rather disgusting mustache, which I do remember. Reynolds, like Craig, is unlikely to fall down to the Reds at 35, but if he did and if they don’t take an outfielder with the first pick, he could be a strong pick-up.


Photo from

Reynolds is the definition of a vanilla player, lacking the one definitive tool to give his game his flavor. That assessment sounds much worse than it is: Reynolds just does everything well. He hits for contact, has some pop, runs a bit better than most, and can cover the outfield with ease. His arm is a bit weak to stay in center, but if that’s his only knock, it’s not a reason to pass.

On the season, Reynolds is hitting .335/.462/.615, championing another very good Vanderbilt team. Again, the pop is there as he has lead the team in homers with 13 and doubles with 16. Reynolds is a bit of a Joey Votto-like hitter, in that he will walk quite a bit but with it comes his fair share of strikeouts.

He’s a safe hitter, one that will rise through the ranks quickly and maybe make an All-Star game or two, but don’t expect much more than that.

Vanderbilt plays Xavier today at 7 CST in the Nashville Regional.

Zack Collins (C, University of Miami)


Photo from

The Reds have actually picked Zack Collins before, back in 2013, and should do so again especially considering the uncertainty around Devin Mesoraco’s future career. Granted, the Reds haven’t had too much luck with Miami catchers in the past, but Collins could be the exception.

On the year, Collins hit .364/.540/.630, while mashing 12 homers. Long been billed an offensive catcher, Collins has had problems behind the plate, hence why he may just fall to the Reds at 35. But the bat is there, and that’s all the Reds really need at this point. Collins is another guy who walks more than he strikes out and is extremely durable evidenced by his starting 54 of Miami’s 56 games.

Along with Ray, Collins was named a Golden Spikes semifinalist, proving his worth to the number three overall ranked Miami Hurricanes. Ultimately, if he’s available, the Reds should pick up Collins. Mesoraco’s career seems to be done or at least continuing in a severely diminished capacity, and Collins could be up in no time to take the reins.

Miami plays Stetson today at 6 CST in the Miami Regional.

About The Author

Wesley - or Wes, whichever really - first fell in love with the Reds because of Ken Griffey Jr.'s smooth swing and shining smile. Ever since that first infatuation, it has been tortured fandom broken up by a blown 2-0 lead to the Giants and a Roy Halladay no-hitter - but that's neither here nor there. The only things Wes loves as much as the Reds are pancakes, flannels, and Vanderbilt baseball. You can find more of his writing at or his carefully curated retweets @_wesjenks.

Related Posts

12 Responses

  1. The Duke

    It’s not so much of convincing Craig to play 3B, it’s that most people don’t think he’ll be able to. He would love to play 3B. He has plenty of arm, but his feet are sloooooow.

    A name to watch for at #43 I think we could nab is Clemson C Chris Okey. We weren’t afraid to take Grandal when we had Mesoraco, and Tyler Stephenson is many years away and given how much time he is missing with injuries this year could very likely be repeating in Dayton next year. Okey should be able to handle jumping straight to Daytona after playing in Billings after being drafted. Okey has very good bat speed, a bit of pop, good plate discipline and while he won’t be a GG catcher, most expect him to stick there. His upside is a .270/.340 catcher who can hit 15-20 HR a year.

    I think we’ll be looking at a HS arm who falls because of bonus demands at #35. Matt Manning reportedly has a $5 million price tag to go along with his 96-96 mph fastball.

  2. WVRedlegs

    I think OF Kyle Lewis will be the pick at #2.
    At #35 high school SS Drew Mendoza will be the pick.
    At #43 college C Jameson Fisher might be the pick.
    3 outstanding bats at positions of need. All 3 superb in the field.

    • The Duke

      Jameson Fisher plays 1B, Drew Mendoza is going to be a 3B as a pro (He’s already 6’4″ and 200 lbs), an Kyle Lewis likely moves to RF albeit some think he has a chance at sticking in CF.

      • WVRedlegs

        Lewis projects more as a corner OF anyway. That is what I would be drafting him for. If they don’t get Senzel, who may or may not be a 3B, then the Mendoza pick is a safe one for 3B or SS. Some project Senzel as a 2B down the road anyway.
        Fisher is rated at one site as the #3 available C, but I know he does play 1B too. But he was the leading hitter in NCAA D-1 with a .437/.564/.716 slash. I’ll take that bat any day.

  3. Shchi Cossack

    if the Phanatics do not select Puk at #1-1, this draft could get crazy very quickly. There really isn’t much difference in the top 8-10 picks in this season’s draft. Maybe it’s just my perception, but there seems to be a increased priority and valuation for hitters, except for the very elite pitching prospects. Since the comp picks are tradeable, the Reds might get active after the end of the 1st round if the right player falls into that range.

  4. lwblogger2

    Is Craig’s nickname really “Big Donkey”? Sounds familiar somehow 😉

    +100 for the Bo Jackson Techmo reference!

  5. Steve Schoenbaechler

    I don’t care who they get. If it’s a starting pitcher, though, I’m going to croak. That’s the last thing we need. Not unless there’s simply nothing else out there with the pick we have, I would probably look to stay away from pitchers until after the 3rd round at minimum. We need regular everyday players who can hit, period. Forget HR’s, forget slugging. We need BA, OBP, similar stats.

    • Michael E

      It might be an SP. The only one to be considered though is Groome. If they take Puk and his mediocre college ERA and bad back, I will be pissed. This dude is a walking red flag. So what if he is 6’7″ and throws high 90s. He can’t even get college hitters out consistently, even now as an upperclassman, and he has a back that flares up. PASS.

      Groome on the other hand, is worth the risk given his huge upside (being compared to Kershaw when he was drafted), IF they don’t go with a hitter.

      Senzel scouting reports say he doesn’t do anything really well. So you’re looking at a high floor, low ceiling type. I hope they pass IF that is true. Having Boras as an agent makes it easy to pass if so.

      The Reds need top shelf talent. The kind that end up on every sites Top 20 MLB prospects lists and not just the kind that end up on the Reds top 10 prospect list. We need franchise types, and if that is a pitcher, so be it.

  6. Michael E

    I am soured on Puk, due to ineffectiveness in college (his stats are mediocre) and his back. I hope they pass on him. We don’t need such terribly high risk.

    I am also down on Senzel. This is the pick if Walt’s we want MLB ready players mantra is adhered to (read it as, we want high floor, low ceiling, low upside guys, low risk, low reward). Senzel does everything, but nothing really well. I think this is aiming too low for the 2nd overall pick. He is represented by Boras, so that should scare the Reds away.

    I hope they pass on Puk and Senzel and go for the higher upside talents, even if they need more time to get to MLB. Groome sounds too good to pass up, even if we need hitting. I am fine with the SS Perez that is along the lines of a slightly less Correa. I’d even be fine with Ray, Lewis or a couple of the HS hitters (Rutherford and others).

    Just stay away from Puk and his bad back and less-than-stellar results. I can live with Senzel, but it just reaks of “playing it safe” when a team like the Reds need to swing for the fences when it comes to the top 10 list. We already got surplus quantity of talent, now we need to add to the top tier quality bin as most of the quantity are role players and low WAR types (at least that’s how it appears).

    • Wesley Jenkins

      Personally, I hope they pick up Ray. I love everything about the guy and I think his athleticism could make him a super dynamic player very quickly.
      My only qualm with Groome is that he’s a high schooler. Knowing how hard high school pitchers are worked and the prevalence of Tommy John, I wouldn’t chance it. I’m also admittedly biased towards college players.
      But I agree with your assessment of Puk and Senzel, and at the end of the day, think Ray is just a touch better than Lewis.

  7. RedMountain

    What makes you think any of these guys will be stars when some of the biggest stars got drafted in later rounds. Votto went in the second round-guessing who will be a star is a crap shoot.