The Reds are 4-5 through the first nine games of this 10-game homestand, and they need a win this afternoon to even up both the homestand and the series against the Dodgers.


Taking the ball for Cincinnati is right-hander Alfredo Simon. Simon, of course, was pulled into the rotation in Spring Training to replace the injured Mat Latos. With Latos returning this weekend, all signs point to Simon remaining in the rotation with Tony Cingrani going to either the bullpen or AAA.

How much longer can the Reds rely on Simon to start every 5 days? Simon has pitched 74.1 innings this season, which is exactly the average number of innings he has thrown for the Reds over the prior two seasons. Only three times in his 13 seasons as a professional has Simon thrown more than 100 innings. His outings have been less than stellar lately, having allowed 11 runs in his last 3 starts (16 innings.)

Dodgers starter Zack Greinke has also hit a bit of a lull recently. Before his last start against Cincinnati on May 27, Greinke had a 2.01 ERA. In his last three starts, including that Reds game, Greinke has allowed 10 earned runs over 20.2 innings.

Today’s lineup includes Skip Schumaker leading off and playing leftfield, while Roger Bernadina takes over in centerfield and bats 7th. Each player also made a start in the May 27th game against Greinke, and they each had a single.

1. Skip Schumaker (L) LF
2. Todd Frazier (R) 3B
3. Joey Votto (L) 1B
4. Brandon Phillips (R) 2B
5. Jay Bruce (L) RF
6. Devin Mesoraco (R) C
7. Roger Bernadina (L) CF
8. Zack Cozart (R) SS
9. Alfredo Simon (R) P

For the Dodgers, Hanley Ramirez was a late scratch in yesterday’s game due to irritation around the AC joint in his right shoulder. Miguel Rojas takes his place again today and bats 8th.

I’d love to see the Reds kick off a long winning streak here as they head off onto a long road trip. Discuss the game and their second consecutive victory against the Dodgers here. Go Reds!

123 Responses

  1. Steve Mancuso

    I was excited to see Billy Hamilton’s walk and line-drive single last night (stood and cheered, promise). But it really says something when a team has to sit its *leadoff hitter* because the other team’s pitcher is too much of a mismatch. It’s *leadoff* hitter.

    • reaganspad

      I agree Steve on Billy’s day yesterday.

      Maybe Big Lutz should be in the lineup today cause he had 2 hits in said game on May 27

      • Michael J Hampton

        Big Lutz needs to keep playing in AAA unitl hopefully he gets back in the groove and gets his timing back after Price refused to play him while he was with the big club.

    • Cinvenfan

      Yeah, it says is Baker all over again. It won’t matter though, they’ll probably get 3 hits anyway and a walk from the OBP King.

    • ProspectCincy

      Nicely done Steve. 4 AB’s vs Greinke in LA a couple of weeks ago, Hamilton lined out twice, grounded out twice.

    • jcredlegs

      Geez. Schumacher is playing because he hits Greinke well. Has nothing to do with Hamilton.

    • Steve Mancuso

      Bernadina is playing for Hamilton today because he has a record of hitting a curveball. Price, before the game, said it was a match-up situation. That’s a polite way of saying what I said.

      I don’t get it. When Billy faces a pitcher like Wainwright, and goes 0-4, we’re told that we shouldn’t count that because of how good the pitcher is. Well, Greinke is just as good as Wainwright. Nothing wrong with what Price is doing.

      I just wonder how many times other teams don’t play their lead-off hitter because of “match-ups”.

      • Michael J Hampton

        I don’t know, seems to me Price just wants to rest him a dat, and if you are going to rest a guy why not pick a day when he would be going against a guy who gives him some matchup problems. I don’t think Price was implying that Hamilton wasn’t playing because he would be a total mis-match against Grienke. There is not a Red that could not use an occasional day off and there is not a Red who does not have some kind of a matchup problem against some pitcher, even Votto.

        Price’s comments regarding sitting Hamilton were:

        “He didn’t play every day when he was up in September. He did go to Puerto Rico [for winter ball],” Reds manager Bryan Price said. “That kind of wore him down, I think. But he does play center field. He’s 160 pounds. He plays hard. He runs hard. He does everything at 100 percent, which great.

        “But I want to make sure he’s still strong and healthy going into the latter months of the season.”

      • charlottencredsfan

        Uh yeah, that is a bit different than what the original post inferred. Thanks for doing the research and clearing this up.

      • Steve Mancuso

        I was listening to the pre-game interview on the radio. The first reason he gave for sitting Hamilton was the match-up. Said the Bernadina had a better record against pitchers like Greinke with a curve ball. Not only Greinke but he also mentioned Arroyo.

    • Drew

      It says we have a smart manager who knows he has a very young raw “leadoff hitter” who he would like to put in the best positions for him to be successful and figured today against a very good pitcher would be a good day to get a bench player who has had some success get a start. Sound baseball from a baseball guy not bouned by just stats.

  2. Steve Mancuso

    Today’s game (12:35 p.m.) is being televised nationally on the MLB network.

  3. Jake

    You mean on I can never watch Reds games on there due to the blackout

    • Greg Dafler

      No, he means MLB Network. I know it is carried by the satellite carriers (DISH and DirectTV). According to this link, it is also on Cincinnati Time Warner channel 326.

  4. Reed Tom

    A sixteen game road trip coming up after today punctuated by three games with Toronto at home.

    • the next janish

      That sounds like a winning combination for the rest of June!

  5. Matt WI

    Uh Oh… rocky start here. Simon may be having a rough day.

  6. Matt WI

    Yes… getting after Grienke! Votto double. Atta boy Joey.

  7. Chris

    This day Simon will need far more runs by our guys.

  8. Sparky

    I never understood how some guys get days off and others don’t. Hammy should be in every freaking day just like they run Bruce out there.

    • Matt WI

      Even Bruce usually gets thrown a day off against a tough lefty.

      • Sparky

        Rarely…….Very Rarely……Remember those long 0-fer months where he just kept on keeping on it the lineup?

      • CP

        I guess I don’t understand what Hamilton has done that would favor him playing every single day?

        Since he is young and has potential (and the Reds called him up for some reason), he should play the majority of the time. But that doesn’t mean he has to play 100% of the time. In fact, based on his struggles, I think the Reds should have already started giving some of his games to Heisey & Schumaker. Hamilton’s style of play is pretty hard on the body, and his stinking up the joint offensively has to be hard on the psyche.

  9. Sparky

    Steiner.. “Great American Small Park”. Awesome!

  10. Chris

    I’m THRILLED Brandon’s bat on ball was constructive – even if the Dodgers had made the play.

  11. vared

    I’m probably in the minority on this, but I wish Brantley didn’t feel the need to talk constantly during Marty’s innings of play-by-play. Typically he’s just stating the obvious.

    • Chris

      Ironically, so are you at the moment. 😉

  12. jcredlegs

    I cannot stand replay. That just broke the Reds momentum and gave Greinke a chance to settle down when we had him on the ropes.

  13. Chris

    Just curious – which strikeout bugs you more as a baseball fan? A) Swinging and missing ball four OR B) Taking strike three. I hate them both but think I hate taking strike three a little more.

    • Sparky

      For me its about how often that player repeats the offense.

      • Chris

        Which offense? The take or the miss?

      • Sparky

        Both! Hate it when Cozy or Bruce swing at ball 4. Although Bruce seems to be improved in that dept this year.

  14. Eric the Red

    A) The Dodgers announcers whine as much as the team. B) I think Phillips was probably out, but I didn’t see conclusive proof. We’ve lost more obvious challenges before.

  15. Eric the Red

    I can’t figure out why Simon doesn’t strike out more batters. Mid-90s fastball, good control of multiple pitches….he should strike out a lot more.

      • Eric the Red

        I watch a lot of baseball and feel I have a decent understanding of the game, but I don’t even have the beginnings of a theory as to why his K/9 rate is so low.

  16. Chris

    Anyone of you stat geeks have the numbers on Reds pitchers who have an 0 – 2 count on the batter and then throw ball one? I know you hate to give up an 0 – 2 hit on a juicy pitch (point being it’s juicy) but it seems like if you’re batting against our pitchers, when down two strikes, you definitely rest your bat on the next pitch and be gifted that first ball. I’m gonna guess it’s 99.7% of the time.

    • VaRedsFan

      Our guys seem to the the “obvious” ball. I wish they would try to throw the perfect pitch…outside corner at the knees.

  17. Vicferrari

    Gameday has all 3 balls to Goron in the zone, whats the impression on Mes called strike 3 as it mostly was outside

  18. Redgoggles

    One positive that I’ve seen in the past week or so is that Cozart seems to be hitting the other way more often. I would sacrifice his power for about 25 points in BA and less strikeouts.

    • VaRedsFan

      +1….I noticed that too…he’s a much better hitter when he doesn’t try to pull.

  19. charlottencredsfan

    Simon is doing his job, let’s get a couple more runs – top of the lineup.

  20. Vicferrari

    Be nice to get some more runs- can they get 4 more innings out of Simon? Is everyone availble in the pen?

    • charlottencredsfan

      Can’t imagine that Broxton is. Threw nearly 40 pitches yesterday.

  21. Spro

    Nice quick last couple of innings for Simon. Now at a more respectable pace through 4

    • Vicferrari

      Not sure we are ready to trust Hoover with a lead, hopefully Simon can go 7 or even 8.

      • Vicferrari

        I think a tired Simon is better than any options the Reds have in the bullpen before its time for teh Cuban Missle, hopefully he can make it to the 8th and Chapman can Bail him out if runs into trouble. 80 pitches through 6- should be able to get through the 7th

  22. George Mirones

    Interesting to listen to Dodger announcers talk about the Dodger offence not being able to hit in scoring situations.

  23. Matt WI

    Ok Redlegs… go get some runs. I have meetings for the next 3 hours, so I expect to see a “W” when I check back in.

  24. Dale Pearl

    I show up just in time to see a strike em out throw em out. Nice job Simon and Mes.

    • Whoa Bundy!

      3rd in the NL in homers. Gold glove defense at 3B. Yeah, he’s ok.

  25. VaRedsFan

    Trouble a brewin’. Limit this to 1 run and I’ll be happy.

    • VaRedsFan

      or NONE!…Way to go Simon…Good thing he didn’t look at his future stat projections. *rolls eyes icon*

      • charlottencredsfan

        Do you think the next Game Thread intro will say something to the effect of, “Simon is ready to blow up any time now and let’s pray it’s not today”? I get a kick out of it and hope he goes through the end of the year proving the naysayers wrong.

      • VaRedsFan

        We only get updates on that when he (or Billy) has off games.

      • charlottencredsfan

        Pretty much, I mean they are Reds right?? Makes you wonder sometimes.

  26. Shchi Cossack

    Way to stiffen up Simon!!! Grienke out of the game now for a pinch hitter. Let’s get that 3rd out now.

    • charlottencredsfan

      29 pitches yesterday so maybe a batter or two? Unlikely and Sam should be fresh.

      • Dale Pearl

        I’d almost say roll Cingrani out there for the 8th and see what he does. But…. not really fair to the guy to just throw him in the fire. Lecure 8th and Chapman for the 9th is probably the safest call.

  27. VaRedsFan

    Simon at 92 pitches…let him start the inning, and bring Chappy in if trouble arises

  28. Shchi Cossack

    I’m OK with Simon starting the 8th, but Price better have LeCure and Chapman warming up and ready to go if Simon gets in trouble.

    • Vicferrari

      Was it really necessary to have Simon face Gonzalez, I am glad it worked out- make the double switch- why fan the fire? I think this shows that Chapman is still thought of as a 1 inning guy- if Gonzalez got on then I assume you had a Lecure to come on but Price seems to have a good feel for his starters (thought he should have left Cueto in for 1 more last night) and having Chapman and Broxton makes managing this bullpen a lot easier.

  29. Shchi Cossack

    Great job Alfredo against the best they had to offer. BTW, did Price have anyone warmed up and ready in the bullpen, just in case?

    • brmreturns

      Parra and LeCure both warming up

  30. Redgoggles

    At what point do we start talking about Simon for the AS game?

    • Vicferrari

      when he has 10 wins in June, hopefully by next week

  31. charlottencredsfan

    3 more outs and I would think those are Chapman’s. Very impressive outing by Alfredo.

  32. charlottencredsfan

    Don’t look now but Zack is heating up.

    • Vicferrari

      I do not know, the 1-0 loss gainst Tampa was solid; the 2-1 win against the Nationals if I recall and the game in Philly makes me start seeing a pattern but agree looking at the overall line-up

  33. Dale Pearl

    Awesome job of Cozart he is starting to look decent out there. Congrats to Bham with a sacrifice just what was needed.

  34. Shchi Cossack

    Did the Dodgers sneak Marmol out to the mound?

  35. Dale Pearl

    LoL wow. I wonder what Phillip’s face is saying. The biggest insult you could give the guy PH for him with Ryan Ludwick.

  36. Shchi Cossack

    Somebody has to help out the Old Cossack here! Bryan is pinch hitting for his cleaup hitter with 2 outs and 2 on? What The Heck!?

    • Dale Pearl

      scratching my head too. but it got us another run plated. Makes Price look like a genius.

    • Shchi Cossack

      The results don’t justify the decision. Quite frankly, the fact that Bryan made such a decision speaks to the issue of batting Phillips in the top half of the lineup at all.

      • Vicferrari

        The only obvious choice to do that is that BP is hurt- it is not a demotion of any sorts

  37. Dale Pearl

    John Fay is saying that Phillips got up slow after Turner broke up the double play. @johnfayman

  38. George Mirones

    this the type of game Reds need to play all the time; no stars, great pitching , good at bats, and solid basic baseball.

  39. Redgoggles

    Of course he’s hurt. It’s a rule that we cannot field a healthy team for more than 3 days at a time.

  40. Michael J Hampton

    That was a heckuva pitching performance by Simon. Those 2 add on runs were huge. I hope there is nothing seriously wrong with Phillips.

  41. Vicferrari

    just had to share the Gameday scouting report:
    That was pitch number 15 for Aroldis Chapman; his effectiveness may start slipping, as he holds opposing hitters to a .081 average in the first 15 pitches but they hit .111 off him after that.

    • vared

      Yeah …. love gameday, but it may be time to retire the scouting report feature unless it’s meant for occasional comic relief.

  42. tourniquette15

    These secondary pitches are insane. When did he learn to do this?

  43. Steve Mancuso

    92 mph slider from Chapman ought to be against the rules.

  44. charlottencredsfan

    Last 2 games, the Reds have looked like the real deal. Great pitching, timely hitting, flawless execution and superior fielding. What’s not to like!

    Could it be having MVP back has given the club some much needed confidence?

    Go Reds!!

  45. Dale Pearl

    Bummer that Chapman didn’t earn a save yesterday or today with that masterful pitching.

  46. ToddAlmighty

    When you PH for your cleanup hitter, and also the team intentionally walks your #3 hitter who’s fresh off the DL in order to get to your #4 hitter, maybe that guy shouldn’t be your #4 hitter anymore? Kind of like how BP sac bunted earlier in the year as the #3 hitter.

    You know, just little signs that you’d expect a manager to notice, all of which say “This guy doesn’t belong here”

    • Drew

      How do you see that? There is no question from a straight hitters perspective Joey is a better hitter the Phillips. But then again he is the best pure hitter on the roster, so if Bruce was hitting 4th today and they walk Votto would you say the same thing? Or what about Frazier? I am willing to bet whomever the Reds had hitting 4th today, in that situation, Votto gets walked no matter what.

      • George Mirones

        Drew you may have something. they weren’t doing that earlier in the season, they were going after Votto. Are the Dodgers showing they know something or have seen something in Votto’s swing since returning from the DL?

      • Chris

        I agree with this Drew. But I just wish we had ONE more batter close to the realm of “I wanna avoid pitching to him” besides Votto. One more like that and we are a real contender again.

      • Drew

        I think we have them on the roster in the form of Devin and Todd, both are “trending” that way and I think if we are just paitent they will be those types of hitters. Also we have Bruce, who when “in the zone” is somone teams do NOT want to pitch to.

  47. Reed Tom

    It seems this talented team is finally coming together. Hopefully when the upcoming 16 games on the road ends on July 2nd., the Reds will be on the positive side of five hundred %.