Let’s recap tonight’s titanic struggle….

Cincinnati 4
Philadelphia 7

W: J. Contreras (1-0)
L: A. Chapman (0-1)
S: B. Lidge (1)

–None. Absolutely none. I feel like I’ve been punched in the stomach.

–Worst loss of the year. By far. No other loss even comes close.

–I just don’t know what to write. The Reds gift-wrapped that game, put a bow on it, and handed it to the Phillies.

–I’m sorry, I was really going to make an effort at recapping this one, but it’s just too painful. I take this stupid game and this stupid team too seriously. A dumb baseball game shouldn’t make me so mad. It’s embarrassing.

–Some relevant points, via ESPN, and I’ll try to add a few thoughts along the way:

From no hits to no defense.

Reds right fielder Jay Bruce missed a seventh-inning line drive after losing the ball in the lights, allowing two runs to score, and the Philadelphia Phillies took advantage of Cincinnati’s shoddy fielding to earn a 7-4 win Friday night for a 2-0 lead in the best-of-five NL division series.

Brandon Phillips hit a leadoff homer on Roy Oswalt’s fourth pitch and the Reds built a 4-0 lead before their defense and bullpen unraveled.

“I feel like I let my team down,” Bruce said. “It was in the lights the whole time. I tried to stick with it. It was a pretty helpless feeling.”

Leading 4-3, the Reds turned to Chapman to protect the slim margin in the seventh. The 22-year-old Cuban came in firing, but he hit Chase Utley with a 101 mph fastball leading off. It wasn’t clear whether the ball grazed Utley’s right forearm, but he didn’t seem shaken.

“I’m not sure,” Utley said when asked if the ball hit him. “At first, I thought it was going to hit me in the head. He throws fast. I felt like it hit me, so I put my head down and ran to first.”

The ball absolutely did not hit Utley. What a joke.

After Ryan Howard struck out, Jayson Werth hit a bouncer to third baseman Scott Rolen. Utley beat the throw to second on a close call. Phillips threw his arms up and Reds manager Dusty Baker came out to argue briefly.

I don’t know if Utley was out at second or not. The replay was inconclusive. There is one thing I do know: it was an obvious mental mistake by Rolen, who should have just thrown to first and gotten the sure out. Rolen was nothing short of terrible tonight. I don’t know if his back was hurting (it looked like he wasn’t moving well, and that he was in some pain) but he was the worst player on the field (0-4, 2 Ks, one error, and one immensely dumb mental mistake).

Jimmy Rollins then hit a liner to right that Bruce turned into a two-base error. The lights were the culprit, Bruce said, not the sea of white-and-red “Fightin’ Phils” rally towels.

The ball rolled past Bruce, and Utley scored the tying run. Werth scored without a play when Phillips dropped the relay throw for another error, and the Phillies took a 5-4 lead.

Two errors on that play, including the second error of the game for Brandon Phillips. BP really got things going tonight with his bat, hitting a leadoff homer and later adding a single and a double. His defense, however, was unusually poor, and both errors just killed the team.

If you had told me that the Reds would commit four errors, and they would be committed by Rolen, Phillips, and Bruce, I never would have believed that in a million years.

The Reds finished second in the NL with a club-record .988 fielding percentage, but four errors led to five unearned runs. Their relievers hit three batters, who all ended up scoring. Philadelphia had eight hits, all singles.

Four stupid errors. The only other time the Reds made four errors this season was in that disastrous game in Atlanta back in May, when the bullpen blew that big lead. Heck, the Reds only had 72 regular season errors, and that was tied for the second-fewest in baseball.

More error trivia, from ESPN: The 4 errors by the Reds tie an LDS record, previously done 5 times. The last time the Reds made 2 errors in an inning in a postseason inning– Game 3 of the 1972 World Series. Johnny Bench and Joe Morgan made an error on the same play in the 6th inning.

Arroyo allowed two unearned runs and four hits in 5 1/3 innings. The shaggy-haired right-hander, a 17-game winner, used an assortment of slow curves and other off-speed pitches to baffle the Phillies. He reached 90 mph on the radar gun just once, on his 38th pitch.

Arroyo was good tonight. Not one bad thing that happened tonight was Arroyo’s fault. He gets the win tonight if the Reds don’t play like a Little League team.

Two defensive gaffes by two of Cincinnati’s best fielders allowed the Phillies to get back in it in the fifth. Then wildness from the Reds’ relievers made it even closer an inning later. …

Phillips, who led NL second baseman in fielding percentage, booted Victorino’s two-out grounder to put two runners on in the fifth. Then Rolen, a seven-time Gold Glove winner, bobbled Polanco’s grounder to load the bases.

Utley followed with a two-run single to cut it to 4-2. The stoic Utley slapped his hands together at first base in an uncharacteristic display of emotion while the sellout crowd roared. But Arroyo fanned Howard to end the inning.

–Aroldis Chapman was just fine tonight, too. Utley faked an HBP on an 0-2 count. Chapman then got a K, and a grounder to Rolen that should have been the second out. There was one hard hit ball the entire inning, but the stupid defense was just awful (and that hard hit ball should have been caught by Bruce). As Joe Sheehan said on twitter, how many outs does he need to get?

–Some of you said that getting no-hit in their playoff debut wasn’t an embarrassment. Well, what do you call tonight? The Reds looked like they didn’t deserve to be there, like the bright lights of October were too much for them. Those weren’t the Reds I’ve seen all year. It’s disheartening.

–What really makes it hurt so bad is that the Reds were a few innings away from tying up this series and having a legitimate shot at making the NLCS. In a flash, however, everything was turned upside down. Now the good guys are in serious trouble. It makes me sad.

–I love this team, and I always will, but it’s becoming increasingly clear that they may not be ready for prime time. I hope I’m wrong, but time is running out. Maybe this experience will be good for the young guys.

–I have never — NEVER — felt worse after a Reds game. And I’ve been living and dying with the Reds for almost thirty years.

Blame Chad for creating this mess.

Chad launched Redleg Nation in February 2005, and has been writing about the Reds ever since. His first book, “The Big 50: The Men and Moments That Made the Cincinnati Reds” is now available in bookstores and online, at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and wherever fine books are sold. You can also find Chad’s musings about the Cincinnati Reds in the pages of Cincinnati Magazine.

Join the conversation! 138 Comments

  1. Listen, we’ve talked about how these guys look overmatched, deer-in-headlights, what have you. And it’s true, when you get that tight, leading a game 4-0 and showing that you CAN play with the top team in baseball, then it IS nerves.
    I will once again point to the 2008 Rays as a young, never-been-there team that just simply played good baseball and wound up against the Phillies in the World Series. It wasn’t outside the realm of expectations. We’re one of eight teams. We finished just six games behind Philly.
    Veteran leadership and “Having been there” is overrated. We need a manager with the balls to jump out there when his team is being screwed. Joe Maddon, Bobby Cox and Ron Gardenhire have all made their displeasure with umpires known.
    The Phillies are who we thought they were! Actually, they’re not, they’re not hitting that well. Someone mentioned that they haven’t hit but 3-4 hard balls in the first two games. I agree. If we win game 2, how good would we feel right now?
    It’s still winnable, this series. We have to have a team (and fan) group hug and just go out and play. No pressure, nothing to lose. We’ll see Halladay again, unless someone Kerrigans him… 😈
    Some of the bottom line should read: Scott Rolen’s Cadaver should have been sat on the bench more than he was. He’s not waiting to bust out of slump, he’s waiting to burst his L4 and S2 vertebrae out of his back. He needs to be put on the bench. Nothing to lose.
    I’m watching the Rays/Rangers…I wish Maddon was our manager.
    Instant replay needs to be made a part of this sport, but that won’t happen with Bud Selig as commissioner of baseball. How does this guy still have his job? How has he managed to keep even a slightly positive profile, considering all that he’s done to keep baseball in the 1970s?
    Anyway…tomorrow’s another day. Go Redlegs.

  2. @LVW: Very good point. And would also help explain why he’s not as effective with runners on.

  3. Some thoughts on what others have said while I was off watching the Bucks and other football……
    However the game goes on Sunday won’t surprise me. However I don’t really like Cueto versus the Phillies lefties because he has gotten away from his change up and become more of a pure power pitcher. I’d rather see the ball in the hand of Wood or Bailey at the start of the game.

    Pinson, I too wondered why they even bothered with trying to set Uttley up at 0-2 instead of just blowing him down. It was obvious he wanted no part of Chapman. I’ve already said by inference that I think they were going up and in as a prelude to going low and away. I think Uttley was diving in in anticipation of low and away on the fateful pitch.

  4. @OhioJim: Good thoughts. Cueto has pitched well against the Phils twice this year. He just has to pitch his game, right now Utley and Howard are not as lethal as usual.

    But will Cueto pitch his game ? He hasn’t pitched since September 29. We’ll see.

  5. @Jason in Toronto: Nice statement, agree with everything you say. I heard Selig interviewed on mlb network the other day, it was depressing. The man does not have a logical bone in his body (or cell in his brain).

  6. With all due respect to the Reds and their fans look at the Phillies 2007 Playoffs run. They had a drought of 14 years (1993-2007)before a playoff appearance and they were swept in the first round. It takes careful building of a team and fan support to get your team to what the Phillies have been the past few years. Supporting your team and showing up helps the team to bring in the revenue to get the team built up to dominate.

    Talking payrolls of the teams vs. each other look at what the Phillies had in 2007 when they appeared the first time, it was very similar to the situation the reds are in now. I am fairly convinced that if you guys keep supporting the reds and bring them in the money they need to build domination then it’s possible.

    That last game was embarrassing for both teams, as a fan of the Phillies I’ll take a win… but was it a win to be proud of? No. It’s behind both teams now and i’m anticipating the game tonight.

    Keep your heads up, keep supporting and that despite what happens tonight your continued support for your team could help them to build one of the most dominant teams in the NL.

Comments are closed.

About Chad Dotson

Blame Chad for creating this mess. Chad launched Redleg Nation in February 2005, and has been writing about the Reds ever since. His first book, "The Big 50: The Men and Moments That Made the Cincinnati Reds" is now available in bookstores and online, at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and wherever fine books are sold. You can also find Chad's musings about the Cincinnati Reds in the pages of Cincinnati Magazine.


2010 Post-Season, 2010 Reds, Titanic Struggle Recap


, , , , , , ,